Re:Did Stack Exchange staff members assist in the apprehensi...
by logn on Sunday October 06, 2013 @08:10PM
(#6505980)
My 'know everything' comment was a slight exaggeration for effect. I didn't say they fabricate evidence (you said that) or that they divulge their secrets to every prosecutor (those are your words, portrayed as mine).
You have a good point though that maybe my comment is not constructive. I don't wish for this to become a cliche response on HN that it 'must have been the NSA' but we must acknowledge that they posses powers of surveillance the world has never before seen (except if you believe in God... however, we actually have architecture diagrams and proof of the NSA technology... not just 'The Book of Edward').
But yeah, it's dangerous to dismiss the NSA entirely and dangerous to make it a given they're more powerful than they are. However, given their secrecy, that's all a fairly expected situation for us.
Parallel construction doesn't actually imply that the NSA is omniscient and that the entire rest of the American justice system is a charade meant to mask its power from the muggles. The NSA doesn't know everything. They don't see everything. They don't whisper words of power into the ears of every prosecutor, and a dark man smoking a cigarette doesn't appear from out of the shadows with fabricated evidence for the Department of Justice and a dossier from ten minutes into the future every time a hacker opens their browser.
It gets mentioned every time a post comes up involving court case or arrest, and it's quite honestly as useless a form of speculation as suggesting divine intervention as a first cause in science. Assuming too much power on the part of the NSA (and by extension, that no other methods used by any other bureau or department are effective except as a smokescreen) is as dangerous as dismissing them entirely.