I'd heard about that...as a non-Gradle Ivy user, when they started this, I asked two of their devs if they were going to basically write an "Ivy v2", submit their improvements/patches back to Ivy, etc.
Their response was, paraphrased, "absolutely not, we're building our own thing that is way more awesome and are not interesting in sharing". Which I found disappointing.
I know a clean break is easier, and that the Ivy codebase likely needs it, but Ivy could really have used their focus, and I think it would have benefited the wider Java ecosystem (as many non-Maven builds use Ivy to talk to Maven repos) instead of just Gradle itself.
A reliable, flexible and built on sane principles build system is required when dealing with large enterprisey projects.
How do you deal with versioned dependencies with Makefiles?
I'm not sure I'd call those things Rube Goldberg, it's just about depending on small libraries and having a reproducible build if it gets checked out on a CI machine and run.
As always, all about choosing the right tool for the job. If you can solve it cleanly with something simpler then you probably should. Something like Maven should only be used if you're really sure you actually need it, because otherwise it'll be a pain in the arse.
Having said that, splitting up "building" and "dependency management" can make things much simpler. Pip (python dependency manager) is incredibly simple, with the same kind of interface as apt, and if you've got a file with a list of dependencies you just tell it to install all of those. Then you can use whatever you want for the build process itself.
that's all over the java ecosystem, though, not just build tools: android and (i think?) spring both use several types of xml files to build. not saying it's not whacky, but it's def. prevalent.
Gradle is a very powerful engine: we use it not only to build Java/Scala/Groovy code but also to drive our continuous integration/deployment cycle.
Again, it obviously depends on your requirements, but if you have to deal with large and complex projects, with lots of submodules to build, do consider Gradle.