News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why HN Should Use Randomized Algorithms by ChuckMcM on Friday October 04, 2013 @11:21PM (#6499246)
Well there is some evidence that people vote on the title only without reading the article, sometimes even commenting just on the title. So if you were really interested in maximizing karma you would put an outrageous title on it, get some rage-comments to force it to the front page and then the mods switch it to the real title. Not saying this has ever happened of course but it did strike me that blogs use link baitey titles, why not karma-baitey titles?
Re:Why HN Should Use Randomized Algorithms by jonnathanson on Friday October 04, 2013 @11:43PM (#6499302)
I have no concrete proof that this is happening, but it sure feels like it from time to time. It's not uncommon to see articles chart to the front page with provocative headlines that, upon clicking through, bear little resemblance to the headlines or body of the linked content.

Gut-level guesstimate, but the following titling strategies seem to work disproportionately well:

1) Pointed, rhetorical questions (as much as we all claim to hate them)

2) "How I..." titles (usually some legitimate merit to these posts, but if one were so inclined to game the system...)

3) Contrarian declaratives, usually about popular topics. (Hypothetical example: "Facebook is not a social network." This will generate a lot of blind upvotes, plus at least a few knee-jerk comments in opposition).

In fairness to HN, the content actually matters here. I can't say the same for a lot of the subreddits I browse, where blind upvoting based on title alone is a lot more rampant. It's pretty hard to crack the front page with lousy but well-clickbait-titled content here, though we've all seen it done before (and it seems to happen at least once a week).

Re:Why HN Should Use Randomized Algorithms by hayksaakian on Saturday October 05, 2013 @03:12AM (#6499818)
I wouldn't say it's too much harder than reddit. The key is long form content.

Legitimate commentary will take longer to flow in, and allow for knee jerk / blind influence to last longer from original submission time.

IMO the beet would be a clickbait title for a long article that starts contrarion, but ends on a neutral note.

Rational/logical people will take less offense b/c they're more likely to read the neutral perspectives and others will blind vote/comment based on title and first couple of sentences of the article.

Re:Why HN Should Use Randomized Algorithms by hayksaakian on Saturday October 05, 2013 @03:14AM (#6499826)
It's most obvious with titles that have multiple discrete interpretations based on word choice.

You'll see early comments disagree/agree with something wholly unrelated to the topic, and not realizing it.