News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Google Bothered to Appeal a $761 Small Claims Case (a... by anigbrowl on Tuesday June 09, 2009 @04:14PM (#649885)
By that logic, google's decision to appeal the case has done him an enormous favor, giving him double the material.

However, if you read carefully you'll see that google called him up to say they were going to send a check, and then he went into print with his story before they did so. If he had waited until the check cleared and then wrote 'how I sued google and won', he'd have the moral victory, the publicity and the money, because paying out money constitutes an acceptance of the court's judgement and abrogates the right to appeal.

Re:Why Google Bothered to Appeal a $761 Small Claims Case (a... by gojomo on Tuesday June 09, 2009 @08:52PM (#650320)
Google has done him a massive favor, both by flubbing the initial defense and by appealing. Just look at the plug for his new service at the bottom of his latest story.

Even with the call, I wouldn't be certain that he was on the verge of getting a check, if he'd just stayed silent. The paralegal may have been going through perfunctory steps before an inevitable review-and-decision-to-appeal. (She may have been stalling or fishing for information to assist further investigation -- didn't Google already have his Tax ID from the AdSense program? Maybe the Tax ID was what legal needed to pull up the AdSense enforcement history.)

The precedent was always important to Google -- they don't want every minor AdSense rule-bender like Greenspan to sue them in small claims. And every AdSense publisher by definition has a website, so is a potential source of blog-blowback to be taken seriously when their tiny win inspires others.

If in fact he was just days from getting a check, there should be a parade of other small-claims winners against Google who, after cashing their checks, could blog freely in the glory of their irrevocable victory. (His experience shouldn't be that unique.)

Where are their blog entries?