Compare this to other mature tech companies who blow away all the shareholder wealth once the growth stops.
I really like the framework proposed by the OP and added by you.
[Added] IBM
The upside on buying shares back is that it doesn't force people to reinvest in the company - it just shrinks the ownership base as the company shrinks.
The OP deserves the credit. He did the harder thinking.
"The upside on buying shares back is that it doesn't force people to reinvest in the company - it just shrinks the ownership base as the company shrinks."
That upside is really not important for professional investors when dealing with mid cap or larger companies. Assuming best case that management teams are genuinely looking out for shareholders rather than inflating the stock price for their options, management teams are not very good at predicting when their own stock is under/over valued.
Most investors want them to return cash to shareholders in most cases as liquidity for companies like IBM is so big that it doesn't matter if they must buy back shares.
Since it is professional investor's jobs to value the share price, they are in a much better position to decide whether the share should be bought or not.
Also, dividend stocks have supposedly performed better over history, but dividends is not a recognized alpha factor by the main finance research relied upon by market participants(1). Dividends go in and out of favor depending on a number of factors, right now, its probably the market's expectation of raising rates set against the background of increasing demand for income.
Professional investors like dividends because they can simply put that money to work somewhere else.
(1) There are papers that say dividends are a factor, but I'm not aware of one that is widely implemented.
Anything beyond fama-french's 3 factor model doesn't have widespread acceptance yet. There are a number of other models in use, especially by quant funds, but they are not public and tested in public.
1. Pioneers who can survive and search for a successful direction.
2. Generalists who can take that direction and establish a foundation.
3. Specialists who can take that foundation and build something that can succeed on a large scale. (I don't like the Specialist label, but I couldn't think of a better one.)
4. Optimizers who can grow and refine a large-scale business.
Many companies (Microsoft, for example) make the mistake of promoting themselves as a stage 1 or 2 company when they function like a stage 3 or 4 company. They keep looking for Pioneers who are going to be unhappy and quit after a year when what they really need are Optimizers.
It's not that later-stage companies can't benefit from having and keeping Generalists, it's just that the company is too large to be doing the things that Generalists enjoy. They don't need somebody who can build a server one day and code a new contact page the next. They need somebody who will spend six months working on a project that makes a certain kind of transaction 10% faster.