News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by flexie on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:22AM (#6488677)
I am a European Amazon customer and I have had enough.

Amazon is a heavily subsidized corporation. It operates from a tax shelter (Luxembourg). It underpays it's American staff (who are then receiving US welfare as supplement in order to survive).

Giving away delivery for free is a form of predatory pricing. In general, large market players have been banned from predatory pricing under European competition law for decades.

Competition is great but let's not pretend that Amazon is outcompeting other (online) bookstores fair and square.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by liber8 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @02:41PM (#6491008)
>>Giving away delivery for free is a form of predatory pricing<<

This line of reasoning always amused me. Free = predatory? Can someone explain how one arrives at this logic?

If the thinking is that "free" leads to "monopoly" which then leads to dramatically increased pricing once all competition is eliminated, this has absolutely, empirically and historically, been shown to be false. It simply never happens. Or more accurately, if/when it has been attempted, this practice has swiftly been defeated by competition.

Edit: An afterthought: If free = predatory pricing, why do we allow charities to distribute free shelter, goods, and food? Surely these institutions are displacing some sales that would otherwise take place, thus negatively impacting those businesses that would otherwise have profited from those sales?

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by nraynaud on Thursday October 03, 2013 @03:34PM (#6491368)
too bad since in France we have seen this exact scenario happen 10 years ago with radio networks (they destroyed most independent local radios). With the real hard irony that the main network who killed everybody (NRJ) used to be a pirate radio from before the free radio, and a real offspring of the radio liberalization in 1986. Now you mainly have 2 kinds of radios: non-profit and big networks.

Charities/non-profits are heavily regulated in France, and they simply can't get enough "capital" to try this kind of scheme. You need so much capital (basically you're trading capital for market share, you'd better be the biggest when you start the race) that it's mostly public companies who can do that. That is also why Europe doesn't like state owned companies on free market, having the state budget as "available" capital, they can undercut everybody without endangering their lives (that's where the left/right doctrine kicks in).

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by rtpg on Thursday October 03, 2013 @03:18PM (#6491255)
>If the thinking is that "free" leads to "monopoly" which then leads to dramatically increased pricing once all competition is eliminated, this has absolutely, empirically and historically, been shown to be false. It simply never happens. Or more accurately, if/when it has been attempted, this practice has swiftly been defeated by competition.

Unlimited data plans in the US (or almost everywhere else) is where this has happened

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by liber8 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @03:36PM (#6491387)
I don't follow. In the US, we went from ridiculously expensive per minute plans 10 years ago to unlimited, nationwide calling for a pretty low flat-fee per month. This seems to be the opposite of predatory pricing...

US Telecom in general is an interesting example because it's one of the few industries that typically do soak consumers, because of what essentially amount to government enforced monopolies.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by r00fus on Thursday October 03, 2013 @04:15PM (#6491683)
Yes, because we broke up AT&T. Before that, AT&T was pushing that you had to not only buy lines, but the phones from them as well.

Perhaps this was before your time, but there's a reason that Cap'n Crunch and blue box pirates like Jobs/Wozniak had appeal - the alternative was monopoly pricing.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by liber8 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @04:32PM (#6491819)
...right, see my above comment:

>>US Telecom in general is an interesting example because it's one of the few industries that typically do soak consumers, because of what essentially amount to government enforced monopolies.<<

AT&T was only able to retain its monopoly because the government helped it enforce that monopoly by prohibiting competitors from entering the market. See the Kingsbury Commitment.

The only way monopolies succeed is if government force prevents markets from functioning.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by consonants on Thursday October 03, 2013 @05:34PM (#6492276)
That's a cool claim, do you have a source that isn't from mises.org?

Tell me more about functioning markets and how they can only be prevented by government force.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by liber8 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:39PM (#6492638)
Yes, I provided it in the above comment. Go read about the Kingsbury Commitment, the The Willis-Graham Act, the history of the ICC and the FCC. In sum, the US granted AT&T a monopoly in exchange for being able to set the rates AT&T could charge (guess how beneficial that ended up being for consumers).

I don't know why people think the historical lack of monopolies (without government backing) is some right-wing nut-job theory. Not even the robber-barons wielded monopolies that allowed them to engage in "predatory pricing" or the other feared ills of monopolies. Go read about Vanderbilt or Getty or Carnegie. In each of their industries, consumers saw prices fall dramatically, even after each consolidated control over major portions of their respective markets. The fear that they would raise prices dramatically after acquiring their near-monopolies never materialized.

Edit:

>>Tell me more about functioning markets and how they can only be prevented by government force<<

Sorry, I misread your snark. I never said functioning markets can only be prevented by government force (whatever that even means). I'm saying that throughout history, you do not get monopolies that harm consumers unless the government backs the monopoly.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by jbooth on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:24AM (#6488688)
If we're being completely fair, Amazon's willingness to run in the red for almost 20 years and continually sacrifice profits for market share probably has a lot to do with their prices, too.

But your points are worth noting, and Americans might feel a little differently if it was a foreign corporation.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by dionidium on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:31AM (#6488726)
Your definition of fair and square is weird to me. If other companies pay their employees more than Amazon, then it must mean that they think they gain some competitive advantage from that. If that turns out not to be true, then, assuming they're a US company, they operate in the same legal climate as Amazon and can pay their employees Amazon-scale rates rather than shutdown. If they do that and still lose, then your argument seems to fall apart.

Look, Prime is genius, their prices are ridiculously low, their return policy is more than generous, and as long as their shareholders are happy to subsidize me, the consumer, I'll probably never get enough.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by jbooth on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:35AM (#6488748)
As a happy Amazon customer: That line is bullshit. Employment law exists for a reason, we don't just accept "oh, that's what the market will bear" for things like unsafe working conditions or workplace sexual harrassment.

Europeans feel that underpaying your employees to the point where they rely on welfare programs to subsidize their paycheck is not only wrong (that's fine, life's not fair) but distorted and not-free-market. I have to agree with them on the distortion part.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by dionidium on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:29AM (#6489115)
I was careful to say, "assuming they're a US company," because I was trying to point out that, yes, employment law exists for a reason, but Amazon's competitors operate under the same employment laws as Amazon. In fact, I said this explicitly.

Edit: Maybe you're trying to say that Amazon's competitors pay their employees more than Amazon because they have bigger hearts and are willing to crash their businesses before paying (legal, but unfair) low wages. That's a pretty big claim that requires some evidence. I think it's more likely that they are losing for other reasons.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by jbooth on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:52AM (#6489786)
Well, Amazon's French competitors have to comply with French labor law. So there's a mismatch and market distortion there. If they don't want to change their labor law, you can see why they'd take other, ameliorative measures, even if banning low prices seems silly.

At least Amazon can still compete on service and convenience, which are their strengths anyways.

I'm not even saying I agree with labor law in France, I can just see, things being what they are, why this is more reasonable than it looks for them.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by jordanthoms on Thursday October 03, 2013 @07:50PM (#6492925)
Actually, it seems that amazon has 5 warehouses in France, which it ships from and which have to comply with French labor laws. The technology is probably still mostly developed in the U.S, but those workers aren't the ones we're talking about here.
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by walshemj on Thursday October 03, 2013 @12:58PM (#6490258)
And "hard working strivers" to borrow a line from David Cameron don't like their taxes subsidizing tax dodging foreign companies.

And given the Poujadist nature of french society you can add an order of magnitude at least to how this is considered in France.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by GeorgeOrr on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:47AM (#6488820)
Just to bring things back to the article in question ... this law being passed has nothing to do with fair labour pay or practice.

It just makes sure that customers aren't allowed to get 5 percent discounts and free shipping.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by baddox on Thursday October 03, 2013 @02:11PM (#6490796)
> we don't just accept "oh, that's what the market will bear" for things like unsafe working conditions or workplace sexual harrassment.

I would.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by jw_ on Thursday October 03, 2013 @06:43PM (#6492659)
And why is that?
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by jbooth on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:11PM (#6493519)
Because he's a white male at a non-physical job, presumably. Pretty brave of him.
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by wuliwong on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:59AM (#6489339)
Speak for yourself @jbooth, I'm opposed to government interference in the employment market.
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by rhizome on Thursday October 03, 2013 @04:33PM (#6491823)
When haven't they? Ever heard of Lewis Hine? The Factory Acts?
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by wuliwong on Friday October 11, 2013 @11:46AM (#6533860)
When haven't hasn't who done what? Did you somehow interpret my comment imply that I thought there wasn't government interference in employment markets? silly billy.
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by disputin on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:46AM (#6488814)
I would think the other Amazon markets are subsidising the books, rather than the shareholder. Does free market theory expect bookshop competition to be between bookshops, homogeneous, or heterogeneous, between bookshops and consumer electronics shops?
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by dionidium on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:51AM (#6488849)
I was referring to the fact that, despite soaring revenues, Amazon is basically running a break-even business and its shareholders are consistently OK with this (i.e. they aren't demanding that Amazon try harder to turn revenue into profit).

This, plus great customer service and extremely popular/convenient services like Prime are probably the actual reason that Amazon is beating everyone else. The guy I was responding to is bringing his established beliefs about fair labor to a story that isn't about that, in other words.

See here: http://www.businessinsider.com/chart-of-the-day-a-long-view-...

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by jzwinck on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:24AM (#6488690)
Which American Amazon.com employees are receiving US welfare checks? I tried to locate a source for this claim, but came up short.
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by jbooth on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:31AM (#6488725)
It's not Amazon employees, actually, their warehouses are staffed by those terrible day-labor contract places where people show up and wait for hours unpaid to find out if they get to work for minimum wage later in the day.

I've seen a lot of sources for Wal-Mart employees under similar pay levels. It was SNAP, TANF and Medicaid primarily, not so much 'welfare'. Still a sizable subsidy, and a decent % of those people's ultimate pay/benefit package.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by jzwinck on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:43AM (#6488793)
Do you have a source regarding the day laborers who wait for hours seeking work for minimum wage? Because an article your sibling posted, which is critical of Amazon, says warehouse workers get $11 per hour (about 50% more than minimum wage). Outside of major cities, that seems like an OK wage for a fairly straightforward job. If it's not, why don't you raise the minimum wage?
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by jbooth on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:48AM (#6488826)
You're right, it seems they pay $11. I had gotten that info about the day-contracting centers from other places that they staff, at some point. And I personally agree with raising the minimum wage, although not any higher than $11, probably, so that's immaterial.

That's still hard to make a living on at 40 hours and no benefits, though. And it is unfair to competitors who pay a more livable wage without forcing their employees to get on medicaid.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by mc32 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:40AM (#6489691)
I have heard about day laborers lingering around HomeDepot, etc., hoping to land a stint with contractors (builders) who happen to make materials purchases at HomeDepot, etc. but never heard of Wal*Mart, HomeDepot, etc. hiring these people to work in their businesses.
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by walshemj on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:01PM (#6490279)
They are talking about things like the working tax credit https://www.gov.uk/working-tax-credit/overview

As a Tax payer in the UK I am not happy about subsiding a profitable companies work force

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by janesvilleseo on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:33AM (#6488735)
I believe this is in reference to those who work in the warehouses. Amazon uses a large number of tempory workers, which limits the number of hours available and the ability to become ft.

This article may provide a better overview: http://www.businessinsider.com/brutal-conditions-in-amazons-...

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by throwaway9101 on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:30AM (#6488723)
Possibly an exaggeration, but OP is probably referring to the workers who run Amazon's fulfilment centers.
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by seanmcdirmid on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:41PM (#6490546)
Those fulfillment centers serve Europe?
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by alyandon on Thursday October 03, 2013 @04:34PM (#6491825)
What exactly is your evidence that Amazon Fulfillment (I'm assuming) underpays people here in the US? My ex-wife here in Texas (a state that is not known for "worker friendly" laws) works in one of Amazon's distribution centers and makes slightly under $12/hr starting pay with medical benefits, stock, 401k matching, 1.5x + 8 hours holiday pay compensation, etc.

All of that paid to someone that has only a high-school equivalence certificate.

While she won't get rich working there, she doesn't have to resort to food stamps or other forms of welfare in order to make ends meet.

Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by wuliwong on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:58AM (#6489329)
I am absolutely opposed to governments subsidizing corporations but I am equally opposed by attempts to offset it with more bureaucracy and market manipulations. I understand that this is a US vs. France thing but it doesn't change this for me. I would be in total opposition to special legislation for products produced in China by government subsidized companies; a very similar situation.
Re:Amazon says France's new bill is 'discrimination' by spongle on Thursday October 03, 2013 @09:26AM (#6488701)
That's basically the point of globalisation though isn't it?