News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F.A.A. Panel Backs Easing of Device Rules by enraged_camel on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @11:09PM (#6486905)
>>This particular policy was almost certainly not useful. But the overall regime of "better safe than sorry" has proven to be highly effective in this particular context.

The context here is this particular policy, not FAA's approach to airline travel as a whole.

Re:F.A.A. Panel Backs Easing of Device Rules by mbreese on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:30AM (#6487363)
You have to consider the agency and their mandates. What is it that is the FAA's number one priority: to make air travel safe. This means all of their policies are made from that perspective. They are a technical/regulatory agency, they don't really interact with the public. They interact with the airplane industry. As such, it's not really helpful to paint them with the same brush as the TSA or NSA. The FAA maybe slow to adjust their rules, but that doesn't mean it's with malice.

The TSA, on the other hand, is all about interacting with the public to try and make us feel safer about travel in general. Generally, interacting with the public is rarely a strong point for any government agency.

Re:F.A.A. Panel Backs Easing of Device Rules by mikeash on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:28AM (#6489101)
This particular policy exists (or existed) as it is (was) precisely because of the context of FAA's approach to airline travel as a whole.

Sure, it's a bad policy. But it's a bad policy that came out of an overall approach that has proven to be superb. To think that this one failure is an indication of anything is absurd. You can't expect perfection.