News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F.A.A. Panel Backs Easing of Device Rules by mikeash on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:56PM (#6486260)
Let me first state up front: I think this policy was dumb and should have been done away with long ago.

However, I think that "breed distrust in the government" quip is completely asinine. The FAA's airline policies overall have resulted in an industry where you can buy a ticket across the country for just a few hundred dollars, while simultaneously being so safe that it has become literally impossible to measure the danger of flying on an airliner in the US, because incidents don't happen frequently enough for there to be enough data.

The electronic devices policy is/was a tiny little wart on an unbelievably successful regulatory environment. To act like this somehow destroys trust in government is insane. You're basically expecting perfection and rejecting a massive success as being terrible just because there's an extremely minor problem buried within.

Re:F.A.A. Panel Backs Easing of Device Rules by msandford on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @10:18PM (#6486733)
It wasn't a quip that I made up to score points. I think it does undermine legitimacy of those making rules when it takes them 10 years to admit that they were wrong.

The problem is that it's something very public and that everyone already knows it doesn't cause problems. There are all kinds of electronic devices which don't have an "off" button. Do they somehow magically not create EM interference? Tons of people have been ignoring the rules for years and it's taken years and years for the FAA to say "well you know maybe it's OK"

The problem there is that there are all kinds of nutjobs out there who use this kind of thing to promote their own crazy theories. And because the timeline to go from most people understanding empirically that electronics don't crash planes to the FAA admitting it was so long, it lends credence to the idea that any rule could be bullshit. If it takes 10 years to find out that something was overly cautious, who's to say it might not take 20 or 30 for something else? Those arguments can be very persuasive to people already inclined to be skeptical.

Re:F.A.A. Panel Backs Easing of Device Rules by mikeash on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:28AM (#6489106)
I honestly don't see why we should care what nutjobs think.

For the average person, stuff like this does very little to undermine anything.

Re:F.A.A. Panel Backs Easing of Device Rules by msandford on Thursday October 03, 2013 @11:42AM (#6489712)
It's not that we care what nutjobs think; it's that this kind of thing is ammo for nutjobs to use to convince otherwise rational people that a crazy nutjob theory just MIGHT be right.
Re:F.A.A. Panel Backs Easing of Device Rules by teraflop on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @09:42PM (#6486604)
It doesn't matter that the FAA is an effective organization and most of the regulations it comes up with are perfectly justified. The general public doesn't know what the training requirements are for pilots, or how to file a flight plan, or how the ATC system is run. They see this one policy regarding personal electronics, which is obviously flawed, and make judgments about the agency on that basis. So, rightly or wrongly, it does undermine public confidence in the FAA at least a little bit.