Sure, it is a tax dodge for rich middle class people, but if people could just keep their envy in check for the decade or two it is going to take to bring costs down and sustainability up, this is going to benefit a lot of people.
How else are we going to incentivise companies to develop better solar panels? Seriously, I really want to know.
We are seeing the same thing with the Tesla Model S in Norway right now. On one hand people dismiss electric cars because they are not yet as sustainable as we would like them to be. On the other hand they get their panties in a bunch because you can now buy a really good car (with amazing performance) at the same price as a regular car. In Norway the Model S costs ~550k NOK. A petrol-powered car with the same performance figures costs ~1,500k NOK -- nearly 1,000k NOK being taxes. (Interestingly, the Model S is the first electric car that many people would consider buying as their only car. So far, electric cars have been toys for people who can afford a second or third car, and who want to park for free and use the public transport lanes).
It is going to take a lot of development to make solar panels sustainable. The more of a market we can create for them, the quicker development will take place and the quicker they will become available to broader segments of consumers. And we'll just have to tolerate that to push the industry forward, we will have to dangle some incentives in front of those who are able to take part.
http://www.ted.com/talks/elon_musk_the_mind_behind_tesla_spa...
Did you not see the original 8% tax free return for 20 years I mentioned - the uk 10 year yield is currently 2.7%
Spare wind/wave energy can then be stored as hydrogen and used as fuel for both aplications.
The main issue here is that solar panels are not yet cost effective (or energy neutral) -- not whether or not we believe in the technology. To make progress you need to get the ball rolling by creating a market so that you can fund development and gather practical experience. So the question remains: what mechanism is the appropriate mechanism for stimulating the necessary development?
Of course, those with the capital themselves are going to do better still, but that is the very nature of capitalism, hardly unique to this issue.
That is an oxymoron. By definition, middle class is in the middle, not rich.
I was going to make a point that the middle class, being in the middle of the income-population pyramid, are more wealthy than the average. Interestingly, in the UK at least, 71% are middle class, which spoils that [0].
[0] - http://britainthinks.com/sites/default/files/reports/Speakin...
Class is a complex issue I am sure the miners who earn £80k plus pa consider themselves working class.
Also Americans (I am making an assumption here) often like to think that the US is a classless society but you are fooling your self if you think that the case.
Even after the scheme was amended its a nice little subsidy for richer people it's the poor sods on key/coin meters that are paying for this.