News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to make $100k in Open Source by working hard by tedunangst on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @10:28AM (#6482562)
Violation of the LGPL? By the author?
Re:How to make $100k in Open Source by working hard by justin_vanw on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @05:05PM (#6485373)
Sure, this is possible. However, this author is not violating it.

For example, if the regular version were issued with the Pro version merged into it, the author would have to provide an unmodified version in the same distribution lest he violate the LGPL. There isn't much consequence to this, unless he felt the need to sue himself.

However, since the author here also owns the rights to both the regular and Pro versions, he can just license both to the user under a commercial license when including the Pro version, which is what he does. At that point, neither is 'free as in speech' from the perspective of the person who bought the license, even though lots of the bits are the same. The user is using a non-free commercial license. The user could also use the free version under the LGPL, but that would be redundant, since they have the same code under a license they can use from buying the commercial license.

In this case the author says he relicenses both for users who can't use LGPL code.

Re:How to make $100k in Open Source by working hard by umanwizard on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @10:39PM (#6486776)
No, this is wrong. The author's code is licensed to the author under a "license" that allows him to do whatever he wants, since he owns the copyright.

Just because he chooses to extend the LGPL to others doesn't mean he is himself bound by its constraints.

In the model you're proposing (where things have one and only one set of copyright terms that apply to everyone), how would things like Libreoffice be offered under multiple licenses simultaneously?

Re:How to make $100k in Open Source by working hard by informatimago on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @01:11PM (#6483751)
The GPL licenses do not prevent the owner of the copyright to release other copies under another license.
Re:How to make $100k in Open Source by working hard by jrallison on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @01:42PM (#6483971)
Technically, Sidekiq Pro isn't a copy. It's a set of plugins designed to integrate with the open source project.
Re:How to make $100k in Open Source by working hard by tagawa on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @09:49PM (#6486634)
In which case, maybe it's classified as a derivative work of the original OS project? This is how WordPress tries to classify third-party themes and plugins, meaning they should "thus inherit the GPL license". See: http://www.wordpress.org/about/license/
Re:How to make $100k in Open Source by working hard by cespare on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @03:45PM (#6484774)
Is such a thing possible?
Re:How to make $100k in Open Source by working hard by MichaelGG on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @04:21PM (#6485079)
Yes and it's standard for contributing to pretty much any open source project that's run by a company. The contributor's agreement you'll sign has you assign them full copyright for your patches, so they can do whatever they want, including make a non-GPL version.