Re:Fingerprints are Usernames, not Passwords
by r00fus on Tuesday October 01, 2013 @04:24PM
(#6478853)
You handwave around the fact that obtaining high-res photos of the finger (i.e., lab setting) is not exactly easy. How would you propose this occurs? It's not like this is some widely-licensed implementation - the devices are highly personal/coveted and don't store the image in-device (just hashed representation that can't recreate the print).
The CCC could have used a stray fingerprint (say on a glass or the phone itself) but didn't. I suspect they would have demo'd that if they could have made it work reliably or even at all.
Your slippery slope argument seems faith-based and doesn't answer the big questions I posed above. I don't see Samsung or Moto going fingerprints anytime soon - and if they do, Apple is there with patented tech waiting to sue them if it's at all similar. Widely varying implementations of the same thing with possibly different exploit angles - does that seem like a security epidemic to you?
The CCC could have used a stray fingerprint (say on a glass or the phone itself) but didn't. I suspect they would have demo'd that if they could have made it work reliably or even at all.
Your slippery slope argument seems faith-based and doesn't answer the big questions I posed above. I don't see Samsung or Moto going fingerprints anytime soon - and if they do, Apple is there with patented tech waiting to sue them if it's at all similar. Widely varying implementations of the same thing with possibly different exploit angles - does that seem like a security epidemic to you?