How about the more you review, the higher your own pitches appear?
That might work, though of course the reviews would have to be constructive and useful. This is where having a small community is a problem, if you use a vote system even a few votes will be enough to game the system.
Of course, on the plus side you would only need a very small number of reviews to be of value. Any benefits for reviewers would probably be very easy to come up with.