Some quick A/B testing and surveying indicate that "People have email clients configured and they know how to use them" is very wrong :) With an actual contact form we had a massive spike in pre-sales requests, with a direct spike in new business.
This is especially prevalent for business users, who will often make a sales contact. Anyone with a B2B site that only has a mailto: link is losing out!
As to the rest (rich text, etc.) I agree. We built our contact form to push the (plain text) request into a mailbox & send a pleasant information email to the customers address, which accounts for a lot of the points you raise.
Because:
* Some folk don't have email addresses and still want to contact you (it does happen)
* Some folk are using this away from their primary machine and don't have email configured
* The form's are large in-your-face pieces UI and are much more "obvious" than an email address. In multiple usability / split tests I've seen feedback forms get more responses than email addresses. People often completely miss the fact that their is an email address. They're looking for a form.
* A large chunk of people just seem to prefer them - again I've seen this in multiple usability tests.
Personally, I always prefer a plain email link over a contact form - both as a sender and as a recipient.
Me to. But I'm generally not building web sites for me ;-)
(This will happen until everyone clicks Yes to registerProtocolHandler requests.)
And I'm a fucking programmer.
You can hope that people will include all the relevant details in an e-mail, but I'll bet you most don't.
Whoever likes using their email client can click the link. Whoever wants to use the form can do that.
1) Not as many people as you think have configured email clients 2) Filling out a form does not break flow with looking at the site 3) Response rates are higher for these forms than an email address (based on my own experience) 4) a form allows you to collect more structured information from responders
I'd much, much, much prefer a form over a mailto: link, which 90% of the time loads completely the wrong thing.
Furthermore, it allows a customer to add the recipient email address to their address book if the need for further communication arises.
On the receiving end, SPAM filtering for email has gotten so good that having a public email address posted somewhere is a non-issue, whereas having to deal with bots submitting contact form is still an issue in need to be solved on a per-site basis, so just having an email link will solve the spam issue for the recipient of the form.
So - why would you still use a contact form? I mean - if it's for a plain contact form - the moment you want to ask for structured data or file attachments, it might start to make sense, but even then - who doesn't hate these forms where you have to click a radio button for selecting the purpose of a message when just typing a subject would do too - especially when the purpose you want isn't listed.
Personally, I always prefer a plain email link over a contact form - both as a sender and as a recipient.