News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firing and being fired by jamesaguilar on Sunday September 29, 2013 @11:46PM (#6467661)
Cultural fit tends to be code for the firee (or firer, one or the other) being an asshole. Nobody wants to work with assholes, no matter how above average they might be. I have never heard of a kind, well-liked person being fired for cultural fit issues. (Which is not to say it never happens. But it's pretty rare, I guess, that that is the actual reason a nice person is fired.)
Re:Firing and being fired by ahk on Monday September 30, 2013 @03:37AM (#6468260)
It can also nicely hide ageism, racism, sexism, conservatism, liberalism etc. Basically any reason to not like a person.
Re:Firing and being fired by ansgri on Monday September 30, 2013 @09:12AM (#6469375)
Whatever the people think of these -isms being bad, I am convinced that a person has a sort of right to not having to deal with people he doesn't like.
Re:Firing and being fired by jamesaguilar on Monday September 30, 2013 @10:55AM (#6469927)
Not in the us, not as an employee of a corporation. If you don't like someone because they are in a protected class, you just have to deal with it.
Re:Firing and being fired by neilk on Monday September 30, 2013 @01:55PM (#6471099)
In my experience almost any level of assholery is tolerated if the person is a good performer, or has made themselves indispensable.

"Cultural fit", when it isn't an excuse for various kinds of discrimination, seems to be more of an issue with stuff that's not so easy to quantify. If there's a guy who likes going off on long expeditions into learning new tools, and the rest of the team are PHP meat-and-potatoes guys. Or if you have a place where cultish worship of the CEO is the norm, and one person don't exhibit any outward signs.

And the definition of "asshole" behavior can even vary. In one job I worked at, replacing someone's code with your own that works better made you a hero, and it was incumbent on the other person to have no ego about it. In another job, that was tantamount to insubordination, and not respecting the blood, sweat and tears that had been spent before you got there. (Full disclosure: I did the former behavior at the latter place. It wasn't the only reason things didn't work out, but it was a factor.)

Re:Firing and being fired by j_baker on Monday September 30, 2013 @10:59AM (#6469953)
So then why don't you just fire them for being difficult to get along with? Why do we need codes that allow us to hide our true motivations? That's incredibly passive-aggressive.