Yes, I recognize that my refusal to accept that we must all have the identical motivating factors is a prime example of why I would be a poor cultural fit with many start-ups.
> Why not simply stick with the observations of (non-)performance rather than offering your judgements of the cause(s) of the non-performance?
Because I expect any decent manager & company to at least try to (a) identify the reasons for low performance, and (b) discuss possible correction plans together with the employee. Actively identifying and correcting causes for low performance is in my opinion essential to maintain perspective on how and why your company works. This perspective is necessary to understand and strengthen the practices and pillars that increase your team's performance.
- You are cautious and methodical but the company needs to experiment and swing wildly.
- You excel at focusing on a project but the position requires you to multitask frequently.
- Your understanding of the company's goals has become more complete and it turns you don't find them as motivating as you expected.
- You don't adapt to some general work practices re: hours, remoting, scheduling & tracking, deployment, meetings.
- Personality clash with other team members due to age, personality, lifestyle or (dare I say) some demographic factor.
However, 'culture fit' is a reason for low performance, but low performance should still be the reason why the employee is getting fired. If the company has not identified the problem and tried a recovery plan before actually firing the employee, that company has a serious HR problem.