Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ...
by pyre on Sunday September 29, 2013 @11:33PM
(#6467626)
> That this kind of essentially incestuous relationship is allowed should say a lot
How so? Would you rather that the judge be related to the plaintiff's lawyer? Would you not be crying "Conspiracy! Corruption! Favouritism!" then? Should the judge's son be disallowed from practicing law?
The corrupt players, unfortunately, may have enough false-Chinese walls and connections that they cannot be brought up for the violation of any particular laws.
The situation, in fact, is one that has become standard in the US. We can see as a broader example the "revolving door" where ex-government officials join industry and vice-versa. As long as particular, explicit payoffs can be avoided, the overall process of favoring certain players and approaches and having a strong expectation of a payoff in the end is basically legal.
Edit: at end of article - Lodsys can be sure it will continue to draw Judge Gilstrap as long as it files its cases in Marshall, Texas. The other judge who considers patent cases filed there is US District Judge Leonard Davis; but since Judge Davis' son William "Bo" Davis is Lodsys' lawyer, the company's cases will all be redirected to Gilstrap. That this kind of essentially incestuous relationship is allowed should say a lot.