News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UTF-8 – "The most elegant hack" by asveikau on Sunday September 29, 2013 @04:20PM (#6466364)
> The idea that UTF-8 and UTF-16 are equivalent in practice is a complete fantasy,

Except that most obscure of details that they represent the same characters.

> Ubuntu, Debian, and Fedora all default to UTF-8, and have for several years now. You're going to have to name names,

In the room where I'm sitting now I have Debian, OpenBSD and Arch systems. All of these defaulted to Latin-1 when I installed them, in the current decade.

> I can write Java code without ever thinking about UTF-16

Patently false. A char in java is 16 bits. String.length() and String.charAt() use utf-16 units, meaning surrogate pairs are double-counted.

> As for your ad hominem arguments about "attitude" and "maturity", I could do without them, thanks.

I am sorry, sometimes I am blunt and overstated about these characterizations, but it really did seem like the shoe fits. You seem to have an impulsive defense of UTF-8 and an inability to see that there might be merits or tradeoffs in an alternative. Throughout all of this, I am not saying that UTF-8 is a bad encoding, I am just saying it's goofy to "attack" UTF-16 for being different.

There are no comments on this comment yet.