Re:Urbit: The Internet failed (slides and video)
by api on Friday September 27, 2013 @04:41PM
(#6459409)
I think a big barrier is the netsec defense in depth / reduce surface area dogma. There's this massive cargo cult of the firewall in security circles, and if you suggest removing a firewall everyone freaks out and calls you an idiot.
Of course most malware and other attacks today bypass the firewall using "pull" based vectors like HTTP and e-mail, but try telling people that. Remotely exploitable "pushable" vulnerabilities are rare these days on stock OSes too, but again try telling people that.
And by firewall in this context I am referring to middle-box firewalls, not local firewalls. The latter are under the control of a box's user/OS and so can easily be opened to permit lateral communication. Middleboxes are the structural culprit here.
Of course most malware and other attacks today bypass the firewall using "pull" based vectors like HTTP and e-mail, but try telling people that. Remotely exploitable "pushable" vulnerabilities are rare these days on stock OSes too, but again try telling people that.
And by firewall in this context I am referring to middle-box firewalls, not local firewalls. The latter are under the control of a box's user/OS and so can easily be opened to permit lateral communication. Middleboxes are the structural culprit here.