Re:California: The ungovernable state
by natmaster on Sunday June 07, 2009 @01:49AM
(#645629)
Interesting that they cite California's long constitution as a problem, since Texas is in the exact opposite position as California (budget balanced), and yet has a longer constitution (second only to Alabama).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
The main problem in CA is that the voters can make policy through ballot initiative, and get it into the constitution, where the normal legislative process can’t touch it. That leaves all kinds of inflexibility that ties the legislature down and prevents the give-and-take and adaptation-to-changing-circumstance of good policymaking.
"he voters can make policy through ballot initiative, and get it into the constitution"
This is the same case in Texas.
Re:California: The ungovernable state
by jackowayed on Sunday June 07, 2009 @02:03AM
(#645651)
"California’s current constitution rivals India’s and Alabama’s for being the longest and most convoluted in the world"
It's the fact that it is both long AND convoluted that causes the problem. Convolution is the major problem. Length makes convolution much easier to pull off (How complex can you really make a 1-page constitution?), but it doesn't guarantee it.
That said, Texas's may be just as crazy, just in a crazy way that somehow works. That's unlikely though. It's pretty hard to make an extremely complex governing document that will stand the test of time and still function properly as Texas's apparently does.
The reason it works is because it requires a balanced budget. However, Texas' constitution is still rather confusing and can be frustrating for law-makers - it just doesn't suffer the budget problems.
Re:California: The ungovernable state
by krakensden on Sunday June 07, 2009 @05:01AM
(#645765)
I thought I remembered Texas have a budget disaster eight years ago...