News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Email Spying Ruled Unlawful by r0h1n on Friday September 27, 2013 @04:41AM (#6455960)
IANAL but the Court seems to have granted Google's motion to dismiss only for claims under CIPA Section 632 while denying it for all the other sections.

> the Court hereby GRANTS Google’s Motion to Dismiss with leave to amend with respect to Plaintiffs’ CIPA section 632 claims

This is Section 632:

> Section 632 prohibits unauthorized electronic eavesdropping on confidential conversations. To state a claim under section 632, a plaintiff must allege an electronic recording of or eavesdropping on a confidential communication, and that not all parties consented to the eavesdropping.

However, the Court has not granted Google's motion to dismiss claims related to other sections:

> The Court DENIES Google’s Motion to Dismiss with respect to all other claims.

So one of the sections that still stands is Section 631:

> Section 631 prohibits wiretapping or “any other unauthorized connection” with a “wire, line, cable, or instrument.” The California Supreme Court has held that section 631 protects against three distinct types of harms: “intentional wiretapping, willfully attempting to learn the contents or meaning of a communication in transit over a wire, and attempting to use or communicate information obtained as a result of engaging in either of the previous two activities.”

Which probably explains the title. I still don't agree with the title though.

Re:Google Email Spying Ruled Unlawful by dingaling on Friday September 27, 2013 @05:12AM (#6456057)
Interesting, re: Section 632

> and that not all parties consented to the eavesdropping.

Are they indicating that when someone sends an e-mail to a Gmail account that they are implicitly consenting to the 'eavesdropping'?

As another poster pointed-out on HN a few weeks ago, sometimes it's not even clear if a domain is using Gmail. One would have to check the MX RRs first, before making a decision on sending.

Sounds like a useful postfix plug-in, actually...

Re:Google Email Spying Ruled Unlawful by dragonwriter on Friday September 27, 2013 @10:36AM (#6457196)
> Are they indicating that when someone sends an e-mail to a Gmail account that they are implicitly consenting to the 'eavesdropping'?

No, not at all.

There are, per the order, three requirements identified for a 632 violation: "(1) an electronic recording of or eavesdropping on (2) a 'confidential communication' (3) to which all parties did not consent."

The order finds the plaintiffs' case deficient on this point because: "Plaintiffs have not established that the communications at issue are confidential pursuant to section 632."