Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship?
by seanmcdirmid on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:02AM
(#6455648)
I live abroad, and US tax laws cause me huge problems...especially since the tax treaty with China is incompletely in a couple of places (e.g. if I go to the US on a biz trip). Let me educate you a bit:
> In some cases, compliance with US tax laws (even though not in the US) are in direct conflict with laws in jurisdictions where people actually reside.
This is why countries have tax treaties, to work these issues out (though there are some bugs, see above). If you don't earn that much, the ~$95k foreign income tax exemption is also very useful.
> In essence, a US citizen is indentured to the US state regardless of where they live.
Thankfully, I'm mostly an indentured servant to the CCP and every year I get to write a big fat +/- $0 on my US tax returns. But I'm just a worker bee.
> It is creating a growing amount of complications for US citizens that are not within US jurisdiction but which can be held criminally liable for not following US laws even when those laws are in conflict with local laws where they actually live.
What are you talking about? The only law I can think of: US citizens are not allowed to participate in corruption (by US law), while some countries require bribes to avoid sending you to jail. Very few laws affect us abroad, the only other ones I can think of relate to child rape and pornagraphy.
> In some cases, compliance with US tax laws (even though not in the US) are in direct conflict with laws in jurisdictions where people actually reside.
This is why countries have tax treaties, to work these issues out (though there are some bugs, see above). If you don't earn that much, the ~$95k foreign income tax exemption is also very useful.
> In essence, a US citizen is indentured to the US state regardless of where they live.
Thankfully, I'm mostly an indentured servant to the CCP and every year I get to write a big fat +/- $0 on my US tax returns. But I'm just a worker bee.
> It is creating a growing amount of complications for US citizens that are not within US jurisdiction but which can be held criminally liable for not following US laws even when those laws are in conflict with local laws where they actually live.
What are you talking about? The only law I can think of: US citizens are not allowed to participate in corruption (by US law), while some countries require bribes to avoid sending you to jail. Very few laws affect us abroad, the only other ones I can think of relate to child rape and pornagraphy.