Re:Mars water surprise in Curiosity rover soil samples
by kposehn on Thursday September 26, 2013 @05:18PM
(#6453711)
Are there benefits to methane/oxygen outside what you referenced?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mars water surprise in Curiosity rover soil samples
by bfe on Thursday September 26, 2013 @05:44PM
(#6453834)
Liquid hydrogen has what Elon Musk calls the pain-in-the-ass factor. It requires much higher volume tank at much lower temperature, adding lots of mass to the rocket, and it's impossible to effectively seal. RP-1 kerosene has the inconvenience of requiring your planet to have been covered with life a hundred million years ago. So, methane is the liquid fuel of choice for future martians.
Re:Mars water surprise in Curiosity rover soil samples
by jccooper on Friday September 27, 2013 @12:54PM
(#6457955)
Methane, while less dense (thus requiring bigger tanks) has a higher specific energy than kerosene, and thus has a higher ISP (rocket efficiency). Methane is also less sooty and should have better cooling as its a "mild cryogenic" like liquid oxygen.
Basically, it's between LH2 (hydrogen: high ISP, very low density, very very cold) and RP-1 (kerosene: lower ISP, high density, room temp) and may be a good compromise.
And its derivable on Mars. Downside is there's very little flight heritage for a methane engine, so most of this is theoretical.
EDIT: Paper: http://thehuwaldtfamily.org/jtrl/research/Propulsion/Rocket%...