Re:Ask HN: Are macros still an enormous edge in the power of...
by gruseom on Saturday June 06, 2009 @08:16PM
(#645320)
It's both, no? You can always write macroexpanded code by hand, only with much repetition, so in that sense macros are always compacting.
Except, I suppose, for perverse macros which expand into shorter code :)
Re:Ask HN: Are macros still an enormous edge in the power of...
by mahmud on Saturday June 06, 2009 @09:04PM
(#645372)
It's for both, but utility functions also serve the same purpose (which is why you see people claiming they could do whatever Lisp macros do with function/methods/classes/monads/templates/makefiles, etc.) :-P
Macros are for introducing new control primitives, syntax and evaluation models into the language.