Certainly not as clearly as the success of Linux in the server world shows the opposite.
> Linux needs to become a whole, integrated system.
If the priority for Linux is to capture a bigger share of the dying desktop market at the expense of the server market, sure.
On the server side, the whole "framework for parts assembled ad hoc by a recipe for a task" model is becoming more, not less viable.
RHEL's next release will come with systemd. The server market is not threatened by systemd, and the growth market in personal devices -- mobile -- will benefit from its power-management features.
> On the server side, the whole "framework for parts assembled ad hoc by a recipe for a task" model is becoming more, not less viable.
systemd units are much easier to write than init scripts.
The Unix Philosophy is based on building well-factored parts that fit together with small, knowable interfaces (e.g., simple text protocols communicating over pipes or sockets). Yet, the success of Mac OS X as the only relevant Unix on the desktop goes to show that whole, well-integrated systems are much more valuable than well-factored parts.
GNU/Linux needs to become a whole, integrated system. A platform for applications, not a framework for parts. Systemd is an essential part of that vision.
In short, everybody needs to suck it up because this is how things are done in Linux now.