News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Copyright Made Mid-Century Books Vanish by adamlett on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @04:23PM (#6447063)
Copyright is what the word implies: The (exclusive) right to make copies of something. No more, no less. Whether someone can turn that into something you can make money doing, is not and should not be concern for the law. People make works all the time that they can't sell. Does copyright give them the right to expect to be paid anyway? If artists insist on grossly overpricing their work, does copyright protect them from consumers choosing not to buy?
Re:How Copyright Made Mid-Century Books Vanish by alexqgb on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @07:55PM (#6448097)
There's obviously no right to get paid for copies that don't get made. And that's not what people are insisting on when they talk about their right to get paid for their work. What they're talking about are the copies that do get made without any payment in return. That the real bone of contention. And really, it's not even the copies that artists and publishers care about. What concerns them is the money legally owed but illegally withheld. See the problem?

If you - personally - feel something is overpriced, leave it on the shelf. That's how you send signals in market economies. I mean, do you honestly think your rights are being infringed upon if someone refuses to sell you something at a price you're unable or unwilling to pay?

As an aside, copyright protection isn't limited to the making of copies. It also covers the creation of derivative works (i.e. adaptations) and the sale and / or distribution of copies and derivatives. FYI.

Re:How Copyright Made Mid-Century Books Vanish by adamlett on Thursday September 26, 2013 @02:41AM (#6449245)
> that's not what people are insisting on when they talk about their right to get paid for their work. What they're talking about are the copies that do get made without any payment in return

Getting paid for work and getting paid for selling a copy are not the same thing. The former usually requires some kind of agreement to be made beforehand, the latter requires salesmanship.

The problem with conflating the two is when the sense of entitlement it brings to artists who are unable to sell their work. That sense of entitlement is what makes them equate an illegitimate copy with a lost sale (the way you also seem to do), when everybody knows that is almost never the case.

Re:How Copyright Made Mid-Century Books Vanish by alexqgb on Thursday September 26, 2013 @08:10PM (#6454419)
So let's say your boss refuses to pay you. And when you complain, he berates you for your "sense of entitlement". Would you consider this to be an accurate judgement, or would you consider this to be insult added to injury?

Here's the thing about entitlement. Sometimes it refers to things to which you are well and truly entitled. When you make a non fair-use copy that, by law, triggers a financial obligation to the author, the author actually is entitled to payment.

You can be as asshole about it, forcing him to insist on payment then disparaging him when he presses the case by telling him he's "being uncool" (or some similar bullshit) by expecting to get paid. And the most likely response? "Fuck you, pay me."

Obviously, you may not have the money to pay. And even I you did, there's no guarantee that you'd spend it if spending were your only option. For that reason, it's wrong to equate every uncompensated copy with a lost sale. I get that. But that doesn't change the fact that you're still in debt to the artist, and that berating him for a "sense of entitlement" is an unmitigated dick move.

To survive, every business needs to things. The first is a product or service that people want at a price they're willing to pay. The second is means to inflict serious damage on those who would satisfy their wants while refusing to pay (try shoplifting if you're curious about what counts as "serious damage").

And here's the critical concept that is absolutly central to this entire debate: Without the stick to back up the carrot farming operation, the price people are willing to pay rapidly drops to zero, at which point it's game over for the business.

When people casually say "just find a different business model" they never mean "find another stick." But without a stick, the model can't be considered a business.

This is free-market economics 101. Unless both parties are free to reject a transaction at a given price, the market cannot function as a market (i.e. as the optimal frame for price discovery).

Without reliable enforcement mechanisms, sellers have no way to set prices. In this scenario, buyers evaporate and get replaced by takers. That closes the market. Unless the sellers set up private enforcement (e.g. the mafia), the market stays closed, and they stay out of business.

In this scenario, the only people with a truly contemptible sense of entitlement are those who think they should be free to satisfy their wants at the price they name, regardless of the sellers consent. If that sounds a bit like rape, you're beginning to see the basic injustice in the position you're defending.

Re:How Copyright Made Mid-Century Books Vanish by adamlett on Friday September 27, 2013 @10:41AM (#6457227)
> So let's say your boss refuses to pay you. And when you complain, he berates you for your "sense of entitlement". Would you consider this to be an accurate judgement, or would you consider this to be insult added to injury?

If we have an agreement which states that I should get paid it follows that I can reasonably expect to get paid. If on the other hand I do work for someone without an agreement, say spontaneously sweep the leaves off some corporation's parking lot or make them a website, then obviously I can only hope but not really expect to get paid.

By the way, I think that was exactly the point Mike Monteiro was trying to make in his "Fuck you, pay me" talk.

> When you make a non fair-use copy that, by law, triggers a financial obligation to the author

This is not correct and is exactly what i meant by backwards.

The way it works is that I pay the rights-holder agreed upon sum and THEN am awarded the right to make a copy. It is NOT the case that by making a(n illegitimate) copy I 'trigger' a financial obligation. Of course the rights-holder may sue me for damages, but that's not really how he is supposed to make money.

> Without the stick to back up the carrot farming operation...

I do not agree with what seems to be your underlying assumption that it is piracy that is to blame for the artists not being able to sell their work. In fact I think the piracy issue is a red herring. Rather, I believe that it is simply the march of progress that has rendered a lot of formerly lucrative business models obsolete. Do you for instance believe that copyright infringement is to blame for the decline of newspapers?

Comparing a producer of tangible goods of which there is a real scarcity with one who of intangible works which are only artificially scarce, is in my opinion a fallacy that does little to illuminate the issue. But if you insist, I would say that a better comparison would be with a carrot farmer who insists on selling his carrots at $100/kg and then insisting with no evidence to back it up that the reason he can't sell any must be because everyone is stealing from him.

> In this scenario, the only people with a truly contemptible sense of entitlement are those who think they should be free to satisfy their wants at the price they name, regardless of the sellers consent. If that sounds a bit like rape, you're beginning to see the basic injustice in the position you're defending.

Someone who enjoys a monopoly in any market and is used to being able to control the prices, might say the same thing in the face of sudden low-price competition. In fact it seems like they always do.

Re:How Copyright Made Mid-Century Books Vanish by alexqgb on Saturday September 28, 2013 @11:17PM (#6463968)
Copyright is a pre-existing arrangement that binds you whether you personally consent to it or not. That is to say, it is the law. Your obligation to respect it does not depend on any additional commercial agreements we may or may not make. It is there, in full force, a priori.

Indeed, its unavoidable existence provides the reason WHY you'd consider making a deal in the first place, since without the force of law to consider, you'd be free to satisfy your wants without making any recompense to those who carry the costs of the thing you desired.

For artists, legitimate competition (of which there is no shortage) comes from other artists offering different works that are either better or cheaper. Piracy is a different beast altogether.

And for the record, there are no monopolies in the creative world, only exclusive rights to individual properties, an that's a very different thing. To put it in perspective, it's the difference between owning and renting one apartment and owning and renting every apartment building in an entire city.

My question to you is this: are you truly unaware of how the law and limited property rights work? Or are you just inventing warped definitions to justify a one-sided, self-serving, and abusive relationship with authors and artists that you know, deep down, is wrong?

Re:How Copyright Made Mid-Century Books Vanish by adamlett on Sunday September 29, 2013 @04:54PM (#6466484)
You seem to be arguing against points I did not make. I did not argue against copyright. I pay for both Netflix, HBO Nordic and Spotify subscriptions. I used to be a paying member of Last.fm when it was available in my country. I have a paid subscription to Ars Technica, I subscribe to a printed newspaper, I pay the mandatory public broadcast license and I regularly pay for books and apps. Is that what you call my abusive relationship with authors and artists?

The point that I keep restating is simply that nobody who produces anything, tangible or intangible, can expect to get paid a priori. After you've produced something, you have to also have to sell it to get paid. Consumer's have a right to not buy, and if they don't, you don't get paid. Simple as that. Your talk about big sticks and the law is missing the point.

In places like the music industry that used to be a license to print money (80s and early 90s), it's easy to understand why there seemed to arise the idea that there was in fact such a thing as "the right to get paid". And that it was that right that was infringed upon when suddenly they lost the competition for the consumer's entertainment dollar.

You like they were, seem to be fixated on piracy as the cause, but that is missing the forrest for trees. The internet was what happened, the cause of the disruption of the music industry. The internet is also what is happening to print media these days, and soon will happen to cable tv. These businesses don't have a right to get paid either.

Re:How Copyright Made Mid-Century Books Vanish by alexqgb on Monday September 30, 2013 @08:09PM (#6473183)
I realize that a lot of very dishonest people deliberately misinterpret people saying they have a right to get paid for their work.

They do what you've done here: mischaracterize it as an unreasonable assertion that they get paid for work, even in the absence of any buyers.

As noted very explicitly, that is NOT what "the right to get paid" means. What it really means is that you don't have the right to opt out of paying.

If you want something YOU MUST negotiate with the rights holder. You're free to reject any and all offers, of course. And if everyone rejects a seller's offer and / or price, the seller is s.o.l. But what you CANNOT do is say "I don't like the price you're asking, so fuck it, I'm going to set my own - which could be $0 if I feel like it."

I'm sorry, but that is NOT a right you have. What "The right to be paid for my work" really means is "I have the power to set the price for my work". You can accept that price or you can reject that price. But you cannot unilaterally change that price.

You seem like an intelligent person, so I don't think this I beyond your comprehension. That's why I don't hesitate to call you dishonest because clearly, you should know better.

And I'm glad to hear you pay for media. But let's be clear, acting like you're doing anyone a favor is a dick move, for the same reason that a boss who treat your paycheck as a favor is being an asshole.

"Yes, but the Internet...".

But no. The fact that technology made being as asshole exponentially easier does not change the underlying ethics one iota. If what we're talking about is something people actually want, the people who created it retain the right to get paid. They don't have a right to a business model (e.g. newspapers can't shut down Craigslist for offering better, cheaper classifieds). That's competition, fair and square.

However, that's not the same as saying "I still want (x), but instead of paying, I'll just not pay." Whatever else you're doing in that situation, you are not acting within your rights.