News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by tptacek on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @10:32AM (#6438126)
Manipulative. For instance:

* The article's entire coverage of Manning revolves around a single incident involving the detention of 15 Iraqis. But that's not all Manning did, despite the wording of the article. Manning fell afoul of the law by haphazardly collecting and releasing to a stranger on the Internet far more documents than any person could possibly have reviewed, many of which had no public interest implications.

* The article cites the case of Jeremy Hammond, convicted for hacking and dumping Stratfor. Ludlow famously supports Hammond's actions. But Hammond didn't leak secrets he knew were in the public interest. He picked an organization whose politics he disagreed with, attacked them, and helped circulate the credit card numbers of its subscribers to the Internet. The clear message being sent by Hammond's inclusion in the article is that he is of a kind with Manning, Snowden, and Swartz. The only thing his case has in common with the others is that they they share some of the same political motivations.

* The article does the same thing with John Kiriakou, asserting as axiomatic the idea that Kiriakou was motivated by the public interest. But Kiriakou didn't become a "whistleblower" until that label became convenient to his defense, after it became apparent that his conversations with journalists, which related to a book he was selling, had outed an agent who had been in deep cover for over 20 years.

I'm left with a disquieting conclusions about the way proponents of Ludlow think: so long as the accused share your politics, it's more important for society to empathize with their motivations than with their decisions and actions. That's what people who blow up abortion clinics think.

I'm also a little worried about the phenomenon of generating public support for any mass leak by working with the media to promote those leaked documents that are most interesting/entertaining/important, while working to thwart any effort to evaluate the impact of the leak as a whole. Call it "Greenwaldism", which feeds a careful drip of calculated outrage and then harnesses it to attack anyone who points out any accompanying documents that might have caused harm by their disclosure.

Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by kijin on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:06AM (#6438338)
I agree that the inclusion of Hammond and Kiriakou does a disservice to the article. Even Swartz gets little more than a cursory mention. Ludlow would have done better to focus exclusively on Manning and Snowden. I suppose he couldn't help citing some of his favorite but lesser-known characters.

But I don't think the author is trying to "thwart any effort to evaluate the impact of the leak as a whole". Maybe you're more familiar with the author's hidden agenda than I am, but this particular article just looks like an attempt to glorify Manning and Snowden's motivations without saying anything, whether positive or negative, about the consequences of their actions. It just isn't within the scope of the paper.

I would love to read some well-reasoned and evidence-based analyses of the concrete consequences of Manning's and Snowden's leaks. But does every op-ed need to be so comprehensive and perfectly balanced? People who are concerned about the deadly consequences of recent leaks should write their own articles, I'd read them too. Even better if somebody posts a (nicely animated, responsive, HTML5, node.js-backed, CSS-only, etc.) infographic of excess deaths attributed to each leak. HN would love that! If the leakers are getting more public support than they deserve, it's only because their opponents have been unable (or unwilling) to publicize themselves effectively so far.

Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by lucisferre on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:10AM (#6438372)
> That's what people who blow up abortion clinics think.

That seems a bit hyperbolic. Blowing up an abortion clinic is a clear, obvious, and directly destructive and violent act. Leaking information may not always be done altruistically, but political motivations or not it's definitely more complex than that.

And while I can see your point, I think you have focused on, relatively speaking, the mundane issues of leaking information rather than the quite significant revelations that have resulted. These things which point to very serious and concerning issues. Not that I want to say the ends always justify the means, but regardless of the means you're going to have to deal with and acknowledge the ends. I can think of nothing less productive in the wake of these revelations than to attempt redirect the focus conversation back to the morality of the leaking itself or the intentions of the leakers. The conversation about what to do about what we now know seems to be magnitudes more important.

Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by tptacek on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:17AM (#6438429)
I don't know what to think about the Snowden case, which is why I didn't really engage with it my comments. It's clear that there are immediately practical revelations that have followed from the documents he's leaked. If it were just documents like the one that revealed Verizon had coughed up its whole call database to NSA under the "business records" provision of the PATRIOT act, I'd have no trouble calling him a hero.

It is harder for me to be sympathetic towards Manning. The best-known "revelations" (at least, about misconduct) from those dumps were already known in detail before the disclosure; Reuters published an article that did a scene by scene recap of the video now known as "Collateral Murder", for instance.

Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by jgroszko on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:02AM (#6438304)
I'd be curious to hear why you make a distinction between leaking for the public interest and leaking because of a disagreement with an organization's politics? Presumably most people hold their political views because they believe they believe those views are in the best public interest?
Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by tptacek on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:19AM (#6438441)
Hammond didn't leak information about Stratfor! He attacked them. His actions were straightforwardly criminal, in a way that few people on HN have any problem recognizing, and his case is only blurred by articles like this that attempt to conflate what he did with what he believed.
Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by tedunangst on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:12PM (#6438781)
"My political philosophy says this is good for the kind of society I want to live in" is a get out of jail free card? What about the people who don't want to live in your kind of society?