News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by miles on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:59AM (#6436077)
For those who regularly ask why these stories appear on HN:

The president's underlings compile their proposed lists of who should be executed, and the president - at a charming weekly event dubbed by White House aides as "Terror Tuesday" - then chooses from "baseball cards" and decrees in total secrecy who should die. The power of accuser, prosecutor, judge, jury, and executioner are all consolidated in this one man, and those powers are exercised in the dark.

This should be daily news everywhere until it is addressed and we start scaling back the War on Humanity. This is simply not how America is supposed to work.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by rhizome on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:08AM (#6436106)
But if it is simply how it does work, maybe that means it should be changed to something where the President doesn't have as much power.
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by rob05c on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:57AM (#6436267)
IMO the real problem is America's Electoral system. Because there is no rank voting, the choices are the warmongering party, the slightly-less-warmongering party, or wasting your vote.

Even if the President had more power than it does now, it couldn't get away with these things if citizens had the ability to relevantly vote for another person/party. They would simply vote for whoever else was closest to their beliefs but not e.g. killing Americans without due process.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by jjjeffrey on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @03:08AM (#6436469)
You address an important topic, but I think the problem at hand comes from a more fundamental dysfunction within the system. Once a president is elected into office, he/she is in charge for a minimum of four years, almost guaranteed. We can't simply rely on improving the chances of getting better people into office for at least two reasons: a lot of damage can be done in four years, and even then, most of the electoral branch isn't elected by The People and at least some of it is allowed to carry influence from one president to the next.

I believe the most effective way to solve this problem will be to approach it from many angles with the ultimate purpose of restoring accountability to the executive branch. Improving voting methodology seems to be one of many possibly useful angles. Another might be to put weight on congress to begin scaling back the powers of the executive, such as by repealing the Patriot Act, defunding the NSA, etc. Another still might be to support legislation to protect the voices of other power structures and communication enablers, such as the internet, journalism in general, and organizations like Wikileaks.

Sorry, I suppose this doesn't really bring any new insights to the table. Rather, my point is that there's this really big problem (an overly powerful branch of government) that's been brewing for a while, and it's going to take a lot more than a single fix the repair the whole machine.

Of course, any single effort is better than no effort---I absolutely do not wish to discourage!

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by rob05c on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:09PM (#6438747)
I don't think the Executive Branch is overly powerful. Hear me out! Anything significant has to be approved by both houses of Congress, and our Judicial system can overrule all three of them (Something that should never go away).

Winston Churchill reputedly said "You can always count on Americans to do the right thing—after they’ve tried everything else." Our system of "checks and balances" makes it extremely slow and difficult to accomplish anything. Consider the current defunding issue. The Republican party has been taking the US to the brink of shutdown every few months—despite the American people voting against them in the last election. I'm not trying to bash the Republican party. My point is, I think the Executive branch actually has fairly limited power. I think it might actually be better for accomplishing things if it had a bit more.

I think the real issue is legitimacy. One way to improve legitimacy is to elect the person Everyone Hates The Least, rather than who Everyone Loves The Most. Hence my ranked voting suggestion.

I definitely agree we should approach it from many angles. But as you say: accountability. I think the real problem is Legitimacy, not Power.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by Osiris on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @02:32AM (#6436355)
Every voting system has its pros and cons. The nature of the voting system influences how candidates campaign but it's not the only mechanism that affects how government operates. It's a far to simplistic suggestion to say that "rank voting" would solve the problem. For that matter, why not any of the other dozen different types of voting systems?

In short, the voting system is ingrained into the constitution and will not change in the foreseeable future.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:04PM (#6438721)
> It's a far to simplistic suggestion to say that "rank voting" would solve the problem. For that matter, why not any of the other dozen different types of voting systems?

"Rank voting" is dozens of different voting systems; its essentially one of the major kinds of ballots -- FPTP-style vote-for-one ballots are used in two main voting systems (both often referred to as FPTP): plurality and majority-runoff; "rank voting" is used in many voting systems (IRV, Borda, Bucklin, Coombs, and pretty all the Condorcet methods); and there are a few voting systems (e.g., approval) that use different balloting mechanisms -- though most of them (including the FPTP style and the approval style ballots) are special constrained cases of rank voting ballots.

> In short, the voting system is ingrained into the constitution and will not change in the foreseeable future.

Actually, nothing in the Constitution requires either FPTP or single-winner constituencies (except, arguably, indirectly single-winner for Senate seats by way of the 1/3-per-two-years requirement.) Forms of FPTP -- both majority-runoff and plurality -- are adopted as matters of state election law, and single-member, geographically-defined legislative districts have been required since the civil rights era as a matter of federal statute as a response to states that used FPTP in multimember state-wide districts to effectively disenfranchise minorities (the same could be prevented while allowing multimember districts by using a system that produces proportional results -- including candidate-centered systems like STV as well as things like party-list proportional.)

Very little of the US system of elections is set in the federal Constitution -- about the only part that is is the Electoral College for Presidential elections, and even there the matter of how electors are chosen is expressly left to the state legislatures.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by rob05c on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:16PM (#6438804)
> matters of state election law

Yep. There are actually a very few cities which use Instant-runoff voting

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instant-runoff_voting_in_the_Un...

Unfortunately, the people who have to pass laws for non-FPTP voting, are the people it would displace :(

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:26PM (#6438865)
> Unfortunately, the people who have to pass laws for non-FPTP voting, are the people it would displace

In many states, the only people needed to pass laws for non-FPTP voting are the people of the state -- at least for elections other than those for Presidential electors, because of initiative/referendum processes.

Sure, under the Constitution, the rules for electing Presidential electors are left to state legislatures, but once you've changed the election rules for those offices, it should be easier to get people in them that aren't attached to FPTP.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by eru on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @02:41AM (#6436381)
Approval voting, for example. Rank voting is ripe for tactical voting, too.
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:08PM (#6438738)
All voting systems are ripe for tactical voting; approval voting has the additional problem that ballots lack consistent meaning (a ranking, especially if it doesn't use forced preferences because it allows ties, has consistent meaning; "approval" vs. "disapproval" does not.)

The problem with FPTP isn't that its ripe for tactical voting, its that it maximizes the difference in expressed preferences that are completely ignored by the voting system, maximizing the need to vote tactically in order to have a vote that isn't equivalent to abstention.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by eru on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @08:27PM (#6441848)
How would you vote tactical in approval voting? (By tactical I mean, a vote that's not in accordance with your naive preferences.)
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by rob05c on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:45AM (#6438607)
I wasn't really trying to suggest Rank Voting is the best system. Just that First Past the Post is the worst.
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by rhizome on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @04:20AM (#6436661)
Your description doesn't account for a President who doesn't care about getting re-elected. Imagine how much a unitary executive could get away with if they really wanted to.

Electoral processes are certainly an issue, but it's distinct from the problem of separation of powers that has enabled Presidents to carve out immense impunities for themselves and their favored.

As in nationalized health care, the US should be following those countries with higher standards of living and incorporate a Parliamentary system (or whatever) and eliminate much Presidential power, particularly where the military is concerned.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by gdwatson on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @05:01AM (#6436775)
I agree that the president is too powerful, but I don't see how a parliamentary system would fix it. From a separation-of-powers perspective, Commonwealth PMs look very much like elected dictators.
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by rhizome on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @05:15AM (#6436817)
"Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good," and all that.
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by beedogs on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @07:38AM (#6437236)
Rank voting didn't help in Australia where the media is compromised.
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by shin_lao on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @02:52AM (#6436419)
Governments violate the laws when it is in the supreme interest of the country, this is called "Raison d'État".

This doesn't make it any less chilling, but we shouldn't be too naive about it.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by r0h1n on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @03:09AM (#6436474)
> Governments violate the laws when it is in the supreme interest of the country

That's the beginning of a long, steep slippery slope. Who decides what is "the supreme interest of the country"? And who keeps a check on the laws that are violated in the pursuit of that goal?

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by moneyrich4 on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @03:45AM (#6436571)
a new gang of people who usually went to school together, that we choose (usually... diebold ... die bold ... risk it all take everything) every 4 years. supposedly we do this every 4 years to balance the power they wield from veering too far left or right and sticking to the countries interest.
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by zxcdw on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @02:57AM (#6436430)
Yes, we shouldn't be too naive about it, which is the very reason why we should be outright enraged about it happening.
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by dalek_cannes on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @04:25AM (#6436677)
I thought raison d'etat was about a state deciding its dealings with other states solely on the basis of national self interest rather than moral or legal principles. It's that doctrine's failure in Europe and subsequent laws that lead to the idea of 'international law', right?

As far as I know it does not apply to a government violating its own laws.

Edit: subsequent WARS, not laws.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:07AM (#6436102)
I am in full agreement, but I have to ask, why now? This hasn't been news for years.
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by alexqgb on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:24AM (#6436159)
Here's what's happening: intelligent people are having a desperately needed conversation about the full spectrum of related problems having to do with absolutely terrifying assertions of extra-judicial executive power.

This is relevant. That's why it's part of the conversation.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by rob05c on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:46AM (#6436231)
Well said. When atrocities are occurring, the question isn't "why now?" the question is "Why haven't we done anything about this?"
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @02:59AM (#6436440)
If you're referring to the ongoing NSA scandals, I actually think that the government claiming the power to kill citizens without trial, accusation, or evidence is much worse. It doesn't bother you that the random assassination power is only called into question because of the surveillance power?

Here's loweringthebar.net mocking the story in 2011 (this story would appear to be almost exactly two years old; the commenter saying "we elected Change and we're waiting for it" might reflect that this is the Change we elected): http://www.loweringthebar.net/2011/12/for-christmas-your-gov...

How did "the government will read your email" become a bigger outrage than "the government can kill you at any time without warning and without ever having to justify itself"?

(If you're referring to something else, please enlighten me)

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by alexqgb on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @10:03AM (#6437919)
What I'm refering to is exactly what I said I'm refering to: the full spectrum of issues related to unchecked executive power. In other words, I'm not looking at these as seperate problems which can be stacked from bad to worse. Which is not to say people can't consider things in these terms, just that I'm not doing this. I'm doing what mathematicians do when they look for the most general yet concice expression to cover a range of instances.

And yes, that obviously includes the NSA. But it also includes the transformation of the CIA into a paramilitary force, the transformation of the FBI from a federal level police force into a domestic intelligence agency focused on "national security", secret interpretations of law surrounding the the Patriot Act, unaccountable militarization of police forces up to and including the offices of prosecutors (tactics driven largely by the Drug War), and of course, the explosive growth of what has become the world's largest prison system, which we chillingly refer to as 'an industry' as though there were anything productive about destroyig people's minds using solitary confinement. And let's not forget prisons that operate completely outside the law, where the normal rules about trials, evidence, and expediency are a abandoned altogether. Topping it all off is the culture of fear, suspicion, and paranoia that pervades the agencies involved. The unprecedented use of the Espionage Act to terrify whistle blowers, actual or potential, fits squarely with a general pattern of escalating abuse. Indeed, that's one of the most frightening aspect of this entire development since it indicates that the people at the heart of this know that what they're doing is wrong and that it won't stand up to public scrutiny, but they're doing it anyway.

HN is full of people attuned to systems. And what we're seeing here is a system getting completely, dangerously, wildly out of control. And not just any system, but one that keeps coming back to work done by a lot of people here. Even if it weren't for these unnerving personal connections, HN readers are far more likely than most to recognize deep systemic problems when they occur, and to see them in those terms. That leads to a desire to identify root causes, which leads to a general problem in the inescapable lawlessness of the Executive Branch. In essence it is treating the problems and conditions of normal life as though they were a formal state of war, and adopting the vastly more expansive and unaccountable set of powers that actual war permits.

That must end.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by phy6 on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:13AM (#6436121)
Why now? Because we elected Change, and we're waiting for it. The question should be "Why NOT now?". Of all times, when the most vocal of Americans enjoy a popular President, why wait until the tide changes to press for the change we all see is needed?
Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by pyre on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @02:47AM (#6436402)
> Because we elected Change

A little off-topic, but I'm always reminded of this: http://www.southparkstudios.com/clips/248462/attack-of-the-c...

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by frank_boyd on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:20AM (#6436141)
It's not "why now?", it's "why still not?".

If the country that plays the role of the World's police becomes/is corrupt (to that degree), then there is no hope for the World.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by Shivetya on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @05:44AM (#6436879)
Where is the press, where are the protesters?

Its not hard to understand why it does not change. Its sad that criticism can be blunted by the fear of being labeled.

Re:Chilling legal memo from Obama DOJ justifies assassinatio... by chii on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @06:37AM (#6437030)
not sure about the press, but the protests will only happen if this is affecting the average american, whose comfortable life is being maintained - until suddenly, the average american finds itself in a police state, unable to protest...