Possibly, it depends on intent. Add in:
You: Hahaha, guys I can get anybodies cake!
You: Looool their security is awful!
You: Hahah, we could short this companies stock!
Then you clearly knew what you were doing and therefore did something wrong.Cool, free cupcakes! They want you to pay for birthday cakes and pre-order wedding cakes, but they'll give you any cupcake you ask for if they've got one available!
BUT…
I personally think AT&T should also be held to account for their part in what happened. They put all that data up on the public internet, with no authentication required to get it. I think they're at least as culpable here as weev is. (and I don't think _either_ of them should get off scott free - they both played fast and loose with other people's data.)
2) Some are.
3) Not everyone involved in investment is doing something immoral.
You're arguing to put this douchebag in prison, but not for an actual crime. Remember that the next time they use the CFAA to crucify someone who doesn't deserve it.
You walk into a cake shop that has cupcakes with names written on the icing:
You say "Can I have a cupcake with 'Iain' written on it?" They say "200 OK, here's a cupcake with Iain on it."
You say "Can I have that wedding cake?" They say "401 Unauthorized, Sorry that's someone elses' cake." You don't get a wedding cake.
You say "Can I have a cupcake with 'Alice' written on it?" They say "200 OK, here's a cupcake with "Alice' written on it."
You say "Can I have a birthday cake?" They say "402 Payment required, That'll be $15" You don't get a birthday cake.
You say "Can I have a cupcake with 'Bob' written on it?" They say "404 Not Found, sorry we don't have any cupcakes with 'Bob'."
You say "Can I have a cupcake with 'Carol' written on it?" They say "200 OK, here's a cupcake with 'Carol' in it."
You say "Can I have a cupcake with 'Dave' written on it?" They say "200 OK, here's a cupcake with 'Dave' on it."
You walk out with 4 cupcakes. Then the cake shop owner comes out and says "You stole the three cupcakes! I didn't intend for you to have them!"
Did you do anything wrong? Do you deserve to go to jail for it?