Re:Probability and Risk in the Real World [pdf]
by tensor on Monday September 23, 2013 @03:23PM
(#6433537)
I haven't read the book, but your justifications here send up as many red flags as the quote you are addressing. First, a proof is either valid or it is not. You cannot have a "different view" on this. Second, there is no hacker/compsci divide. Terms like 'the real world' are used solely to demean the work of another person and offer nothing useful.
Your example is especially frightening. You cannot build proofs on weak rules-of-thumb. In fact, it is difficult to even quantify values surrounding heuristics like the one you give. There simply is no valid data.
Re:Probability and Risk in the Real World [pdf]
by stiff on Monday September 23, 2013 @03:18PM
(#6433512)
Can you give me an example of a rule that is true ("holds across a broad range of environments") and the truth of which does not depend on a "specific (and closed) set of assumptions"? How does one arrive at "rules" like this using mathematics? I think that's quite a revolution in the foundations of mathematics...
While I see your point about the quote, I think his intent of the definition is very clear. If you are curious and want to know what he means by something, he's very active on both facebook and twitter.
As a specific example, you have probably heard of the saying "premature optimization is the root of all evil". This is a rule which holds in pretty much any domain. It's obviously not a theorem, but you can still talk about the payoff of the rule. This is what Taleb means when he says "probability in the real world" - it's all about payoffs and consequences.