I guess Clayton Christensen put too much focus on the "low-cost" part of the disruptive innovation, which I suppose does happen more often than that, but the way I see disruptive innovation is making some things "10x better" than before, and those things need to be things that the market wants, obviously, otherwise they're pointless.
In a way he was also right, just not about the iPhone - but about Android. Android is also disruptive to the iPhone, and it's more about the low-cost strategy than doing some things much better.
It's also helping noname OEM's create pretty quality devices for very low-cost, and Android has also disrupted paid operating systems like Windows Mobile, and even the desktop Windows, and continues to do it:
http://static5.businessinsider.com/image/523376fe69bedd1c3ec...
So maybe Clayton is ultimately right. The iPhone "changed the game", but it will be Android the one to reap most of the benefits from this "disruption".
It's low end disruption - that the same product becomes modularized - that I have an issue with.
The iPhone was not en improvement of the phone but of the computer which also explains why 90% of the time is used for not ringing.
All that said, I'm still glad that he went out on a limb, and that he was able to fess up to the mistake. Very few business or econ professors are willing to do either.
Apple always viewed the iphone as a computer. Its computers are also premium products, emphasize ease of use, and yet are fashion statements.
The author of the article, I think, makes a "phalous leap" from "He was wrong about the iPhone" to "disruption doesn't apply to consumer markets".
Primarily because the iPhone is a perfect case of this. It (and it's successor, the iPad) is disrupting the PC industry.
You have to look at the phone as a computer, not a phone. Then disruption theory REALLY makes sense.