Re:The STEM Crisis is a Myth
by VLM on Sunday September 22, 2013 @10:21AM
(#6426722)
There is a minor blind spot of the often repeated but completely false claim that there are no STEM jobs or STEM activity of any sort outside SV/Manhattan, so its perfectly statistically possible for a shortage of STEM grads willing to for for $7.25/hr in SV/Manhattan to exist, therefore "the entire nation" has a STEM shortage, although solely in two relatively microscopic geographic locations. I assure you there is NO SHORTAGE of qualified STEM folks in, say, Wisconsin. Qualified STEM folks willing to work for $7.25/hr? Yes. Qualified STEM folks willing to work at Starbucks and sling coffee? Yes.
Another tangent on the topic is "real STEM" work vs business successes. You don't exactly need Knuth to implement "We're gonna serve ads to IRC implemented over SMS reimplemented over a smartphone app" "We're going to implement an online workforce automation website for middle school girls by making a database of peoples friends and then they can play virtual farm games with each other and then we'll sell ads and database dumps". What I'm getting at, is if you want to implement the great wall of china, your limit is always going to be logistics issues relating to grunts with shovels and wheelbarrows, not PHD level theoretical civil engineer problems.
So add some geographic concerns, and add some discussion of real STEM vs grunt labor type of tasks to the in a previously STEM-ish field.
Other than those two mostly untouched topics, its a good article with no obvious mistakes in what topics were covered.
Another tangent on the topic is "real STEM" work vs business successes. You don't exactly need Knuth to implement "We're gonna serve ads to IRC implemented over SMS reimplemented over a smartphone app" "We're going to implement an online workforce automation website for middle school girls by making a database of peoples friends and then they can play virtual farm games with each other and then we'll sell ads and database dumps". What I'm getting at, is if you want to implement the great wall of china, your limit is always going to be logistics issues relating to grunts with shovels and wheelbarrows, not PHD level theoretical civil engineer problems.
So add some geographic concerns, and add some discussion of real STEM vs grunt labor type of tasks to the in a previously STEM-ish field.
Other than those two mostly untouched topics, its a good article with no obvious mistakes in what topics were covered.