News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Close to 10% of the papers we receive show some sign of ... by aidenn0 on Friday September 20, 2013 @12:20AM (#6415892)
It increases the amount of crap out there, plus it pads the CV
Re:“Close to 10% of the papers we receive show some sign of ... by ChuckMcM on Friday September 20, 2013 @12:23AM (#6415899)
This is a huge issue. When you slog through 5 papers someone has written and keep getting a deja vu feeling it really sucks.
Re:“Close to 10% of the papers we receive show some sign of ... by sliverstorm on Friday September 20, 2013 @01:38AM (#6416114)
Not to mention when your deja vu is of deja vu.
Re:“Close to 10% of the papers we receive show some sign of ... by anon1385 on Friday September 20, 2013 @08:23AM (#6417225)
We have to keep in mind what the academic definition of plagiarism is, because it isn't the same as the lay person definition. Reusing the same fragment of as few as 3 or 4 words without direct attribution is plagiarism.

For fun, trying googling "It increases the amount of crap", and you will find that your very own post meets the academic definition of plagiarism. Both for containing a single plagiarised phrase and percentage wise (46% plagiarised!).

I've seen post grads spend weeks using software to look for identical phrases of 4 words in their final work and previous work and then slightly rephrasing a sentence to avoid duplication of a common phrase and the dreaded self-plagiarism. Then running the thing again and inevitably finding the new wording was a duplication as well. I couldn't see it as anything other than a colossal waste of time. If you are writing about the same topic it's inevitable that you will phrase things in the same way at times.

All of this does nothing to combat the CV padding you worry about because it only concerns reusing the same exact language, not talking about the same ideas over and over in different ways.

As an outsider it seems that academia has descended into a kind of madness about plagiarism and self plagiarism. I think this is largely thanks to software companies trying to sell their plagiarism detection systems.

Re:“Close to 10% of the papers we receive show some sign of ... by joe_the_user on Friday September 20, 2013 @03:31AM (#6416419)
Sure but crap as such isn't an ethical problem. In fact, theoretically it would be the job of publications, not authors, to prevent crap from being published.

Plus, if the competition wasn't so gruesome and that evaluation criteria weren't shallow, the pressure to pad one's CV wouldn't be so great.

"Holy ethical violation batman, the slaves are slipping out of their manacles and they certified on their honor they would not do that"

Re:“Close to 10% of the papers we receive show some sign of ... by weland on Friday September 20, 2013 @04:34AM (#6416610)
Yes, it is. It's an ethical problem because making researchers sift through more crap just so that you can pad up your CV is slowing down further research into your field.

I know it's an oversimplification, but the essence of it is true: curing cancer is already hard enough. It shouldn't be made any harder by ambitiously exceeding your dead tree quota.

Sauce: abandoned an academic career :-)

Re:“Close to 10% of the papers we receive show some sign of ... by joe_the_user on Friday September 20, 2013 @08:01PM (#6421290)
Uh, by the token, a badly designed desk which makes things harder for researchers is an ethical problem.

I wouldn't minimize the problematic quality of having a bunch of crap in research or what-all else. But the thing is that, as you know, the academic world puts extreme pressure on people to both follow the rules and to makes themselves look good. When any violation of a rule-set can be called an "ethical violation" when it's really not that, it cheapens the whole concept of ethics. Which isn't surprising given how monumentally unethical it is to set up system.

Essentially, I can't help seeing people with a lot of power engaging in seriously unethetical things and happy to blur the lines between that and people cuts corners in response to pressure (and that stuff winds up being more pressure on people which doesn't actually stop the corner-cutting).

Re:“Close to 10% of the papers we receive show some sign of ... by aidenn0 on Saturday September 21, 2013 @02:52AM (#6422199)
I would say intentionally designing a desk that is uncomfortable and will slow people down, and then passing it off as comfortable is unethical
Re:“Close to 10% of the papers we receive show some sign of ... by joe_the_user on Saturday September 21, 2013 @02:32PM (#6423920)
Parse the sentence above in the context of being a reply to another post, darn it.