Re:Edward C++Hands
by michaelwww on Thursday September 19, 2013 @10:58PM
(#6415729)
I was under the impression he was speaking of parallel programming (software algorithms utilizing parallelism,) not sequential code running in parallel.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
If you want to get into proper parallel numerical algorithms, most useful programs are C, C++, or Fortran, sometimes with CUDA or OpenCL kernels. I don't think I've seen any large-scale HPC applications in Haskell, as much as like that language.
Re:Edward C++Hands
by michaelwww on Friday September 20, 2013 @01:10AM
(#6416040)
I'm not trying to be argumentative, I'm just trying to clarify my perspective, which I think the author shares with me and I feel is not being understood. We know what has worked in the past. To me the author is saying functional programming with language features helpful for parallel programming is a better path to take. If I say I believe electric cars are better suited for the future and you say millions of internal combustion cars exist and work just fine, you haven't told me anything I don't already know or addressed features of electric cars that you feel make me wrong. That a large electric car infrastructure doesn't exist yet also doesn't disprove anything. The internal combustion engine is going away and so is C++. That's my opinion.
Re:Edward C++Hands
by chetanahuja on Friday September 20, 2013 @01:14AM
(#6416048)
"I was under the impression he was speaking of parallel programming (software algorithms utilizing parallelism,) not sequential code running in parallel"
The argument was about squandering the powerful multi-core hardware because of deficiencies in imperative languages. No notion of some platonic ideal of a parallel application was raised.
My point is that the "squandering" claim is clearly and obviously false as I argued above.
Re:Edward C++Hands
by michaelwww on Friday September 20, 2013 @02:01AM
(#6416173)
I agree that the use of the word 'squandering' is provocative and incorrect. reddit points out that he is evangelizing Haskell (FPComplete) and trolling C++ users on Twitter ("I used to be a C++ masochist") He doesn't make his financial bias clear in the article, which would have been helpful for those not familiar with him.
Re:Edward C++Hands
by BartoszMilewski on Friday September 20, 2013 @03:35PM
(#6419988)
Ouch! Ad personam attacks are a sign of desperation. For the record, I used to work for FPComplete (I architected the School of Haskell) but I quit. It was an interesting experience, having seen a whole complex web site and an online Haskell IDE built in record time by a few Haskell programmers.
Re:Edward C++Hands
by michaelwww on Friday September 20, 2013 @03:54PM
(#6420090)
Sorry man! If you read the rest of my posts I was agreeing with you. I was just trying to address the reaction chetanahuja had to your article to say I wasn't blinded and had healthy skeptism, but I still agreed whole-heartedly with you. C++ is great for special circumstances but I'd hate to have to go back to it for general coding. Functional programming offers some very intriguing ideas, which I'm only starting to grasp. I don't really mind you being provocative because it provokes and discussion follows.