You're pretty much making a text book ad hominem attack. You're going after him instead of his argument. It's as simple as that.
Re:DivX Now Installs Malware
by grannyg00se on Thursday September 19, 2013 @12:06PM
(#6412491)
"You're going after him instead of his argument."
That doesn't make it ad hominem. That's a phrase used in the context of a debate. jessedhillon isn't after the argument at all. He's attacking a certain behaviour.
ad hominem: "Your point about global warming is invalid because you slap your children and I don't like that."
not ad hominem: "You slap your children and I don't like that."
He basically admits he didn't even consider the arguments. He calls the person a coward for posting anonymously. He's attacking the person's behavior irrelevant to the argument. Attacking the man, and admitting he never considered the argument at all. So if it's not considered ad hominem it's just trolling.
Well by that measure it's off-topic then.
He could have very well-placed criticisms actually, I don't make any assessment one way or the other as to that question.
Bottom line -- the guy wants to hold PG accountable to some imaginary (but popular) standard, while evading accountability himself.