News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In defense of Experts Exchange by codezero on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @01:31PM (#6406599)
Were the answers readily available elsewhere in most cases? If so, the main "wrong" done by EE was simply placing inaccessible results higher than otherwise accessible ones, which is pretty rubbish, but if instead, a bulk of the content was unavailable elsewhere, this doesn't seem that bad. I'm guessing it was more of the former though, lending to the general ire towards EE.
Re:In defense of Experts Exchange by chrismcb on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @02:09PM (#6406872)
Generally you could find the answer elsewhere. They made it more difficult to find the answer's elsewhere, as they were generally in the top of any query. If it happened occasionally, it would be no big deal. But when it happened every single time, it gets frustrating. You have a deadline, and you have a problem that is already frustrating. Now you have to wade through EE results trying to find another site that has an answer.
Re:In defense of Experts Exchange by radmuzom on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @04:27PM (#6407879)
Huh? You are making it sound that EE answer ranking highly in Google is EE's fault and not the Google search algorithm. I would argue that almost any useful programming question I search for has SO as the first link which is then "closed as not constructive". It is behavior even worse than EE - at least for EE, I knew that their pay-wall would block me.
Re:In defense of Experts Exchange by normloman on Monday September 23, 2013 @10:45AM (#6431286)
Yes the answers were available elsewhere. And if EE hadn't resorted to scumbag-SEO, you'd have been able to find them sooner.