How does a paid site compete with something like Stack Exchange? SE has most of the answers. People appreciate finding the answer they needed. Many of them will turn around and pay it forward by answering questions or improving other answers. It's the same reason Wikipedia killed paid encyclopedias.
I think we're now starting to realize the repercussions of this emphasis on free, free, free content online.
Look at newspapers. Nobody wants to pay for news anymore, and consequently, the journalism industry is in shambles. And that's a real shame, because in decades past, a robust metro newspaper used to be one of the best checks and balances against government corruption and slimey business practices.
The model you propose -- freely sharing information so that everyone benefits -- has its merits, but it's no way to make a living, and consequently the pool of contributors gets whittled down to those who can afford to contribute without any expectation of compensation. But what if the person who has the expertise to answer a tough question isn't in that pool?
You're right that some things that were great ways to make a living are starting to become less-so. The answer is to simply to not try to make a living at that thing that is undervalued by the market. If enough providers of that service leave the supply pool, then the value will increase and compel the supply to return.
The market doesn't have an obligation to support journalists ... if no one wants to pay them because they can get information on twitter, reddit, and facebook ... well, that's how it is :)
In fact, pretty much any company whose primary asset is content faces a version of this problem.
My take on it? This falls into the category of "3. Come up with a totally new business model":
I've often thought that it would be useful to have a search engine that indexes paid content and then allows users to filter it out.
So, suppose you're searching for the answer to a particularly difficult programming question.
You might start out with the filter on: "Only show me free results."
And then if your search turns up nothing, you might turn the filter off, and maybe you'd discover that for a couple of bucks, you can get access to the answer to your question.
So maybe EE, or some other enterprising company, could build a search engine that fits their monetization model, rather than relying on a bunch of search engines that don't.