News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Daniel Dennett: The Normal Well-Tempered Mind by javajosh on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @12:06AM (#6397502)
The strange thing to me is that our minds aren't really that great at studying and describing themselves. You'd think that a mind interested in how minds worked would happily examine itself in whatever level of detail it wanted. One could hope that someone like Dennett could just close his eyes, sit back, and directly observe the answer to all of his most pressing questions. Why doesn't that seem to be possible?
Re:Daniel Dennett: The Normal Well-Tempered Mind by lnanek2 on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @12:11AM (#6397516)
Why would it be? Evolution is mostly driven by getting enough calories and mates. If your brain needed to be twice as big and needed twice the calories to perform self introspection, for example, it would probably be selected against by evolution since the gain wouldn't be worth the cost.

It would be like running a debugger in production. Kills the performance.

Re:Daniel Dennett: The Normal Well-Tempered Mind by jrlocke on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @12:20AM (#6397541)
That's a good point. Further, you are unlikely to pose a serious threat hiding food (or making political moves, scheming to find the best mate or whatever) from yourself. Others do pose that threat. You can see the effects of the greater stakes by way of evolution. We can intricately reason with folk-psychology, "he believes she thought he put the food under the rock but he thinks she knows he knows she thinks he's going to hide it there, so he thinks he may get away with placing it there" but we are introspectively blind.
Re:Daniel Dennett: The Normal Well-Tempered Mind by javajosh on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @12:17AM (#6397531)
I'm not saying that we should be introspective in lieu of reproducing. It's not an all or nothing thing. BTW that same line of argument could be made against philosophy or even large portions of science, but clearly people can (and do) think about things that don't have an evolutionary advantage. But for some reason, direct knowledge (and manipulation) of our own minds is curiously out-of-reach.
Re:Daniel Dennett: The Normal Well-Tempered Mind by PeterisP on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @05:40AM (#6398377)
Larger brain by itself is a very strong evolutionary disadvantage - it consumes a lot of calories, and in humans it hampers childbirth which in out natural state is very deadly already.

There is a strong pressure for us to have a brain that's "barely just enough" capable for the functions that increase survivability.

Re:Daniel Dennett: The Normal Well-Tempered Mind by guelo on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @12:58AM (#6397659)
Abstract thinking about their environment allowed our ape ancestors to be more adaptable and plan ahead, thus increasing their chances of surviving to procreate.
Re:Daniel Dennett: The Normal Well-Tempered Mind by danabramov on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @12:28AM (#6397563)
The debugger analogy is spot on.
Re:Daniel Dennett: The Normal Well-Tempered Mind by bloodofheroes on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @12:18AM (#6397532)
I think you're getting into the mind-body problem there. The mind is not machinery, the brain is. You'll never be able to cut open someone's brain and find the content of their thoughts or experience.

We (mind/soul) are only semi-transcendent, not transcendent, so the objectivity required to do what you're describing is not directly possible.