Re:PHd Student Uses Google Maps To Uncover N. Korea Secrets
by Shamiq on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @12:43AM
(#639234)
Do y'all consider this a ballsy move by the creator (and collaborators), or are there enough people working on this project that anonymity and risk of persecution are very low?
Re:PHd Student Uses Google Maps To Uncover N. Korea Secrets
by jasonkester on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @10:52AM
(#639825)
Just because you're paranoid...
This sort of validates their point, doesn't it? They let one guy in to look around, and next thing you know he's back in the US, annotating satellite maps in his spare time. Looking at it from their point of view, the rest of the world really is out to get them.
Re:PHd Student Uses Google Maps To Uncover N. Korea Secrets
by maggie on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @11:52AM
(#639913)
I'm pretty disappointed by the votes down on all of javert's comments on these posts.
Political opinion is welcome on this site in other threads, this just seems to be suppression of an unpopular point of view.
It's also disingenuous to ask the poster questions about their POV and vote them down at the same time. If the questions are more than rhetorical (and if they're only rhetorical, then that's a waste of a post), then you should be willing to listen to the answers.
If you'd like HN to be a place w/o political discussions at all, then vote down the OP and the link--not the comments that follow.
Re:PHd Student Uses Google Maps To Uncover N. Korea Secrets
by ashleyw on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @09:52AM
(#639742)
There's been a little war in Iraq. A war which practically nobody wants. Why the hell would anyone start another?
Plus Kim Jong-il (and the military leaders) would have to be clinically insane to even dare launch a nuclear weapon at another country. US/UK/France/China/Russia have enough nukes to flatten the rest of the world...it'd be suicide!
Re:PHd Student Uses Google Maps To Uncover N. Korea Secrets
by Goladus on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @05:25PM
(#640456)
The problem is that North Korea has thousands of conventional artillery placements along their southern border. I'm not sure there are any viable attack strategies that don't include Seoul being mostly destroyed.
Re:PHd Student Uses Google Maps To Uncover N. Korea Secrets
by TriinT on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @09:34PM
(#640801)
"Never, never, never believe any war will be smooth and easy, or that anyone who embarks on the strange voyage can measure the tides and hurricanes he will encounter. The statesman who yields to war fever must realize that once the signal is given, he is no longer the master of policy but the slave of unforeseeable and uncontrollable events."
Re:PHd Student Uses Google Maps To Uncover N. Korea Secrets
by javert on Thursday June 04, 2009 @02:02AM
(#641022)
Gulf War? Civil War (from the Union side)? Lots of US wars have been straightforward and successful. And an attack on NK would not even qualify as a "war".
Re:PHd Student Uses Google Maps To Uncover N. Korea Secrets
by TriinT on Thursday June 04, 2009 @02:42AM
(#641054)
USAF pilots have it easy. Until they're shot down over enemy territory, that is...
I know nothing about NK's nuclear capabilities, but I doubt a few well-place JDAMS would do the job. Bombing nuclear facilities is not trivial. Israel did it successfully once, though.
A pre-emptive attack on NK could be a great idea, or it could be a disaster. There are thousands of U.S. soldiers in South Korea. An attack on NK would give them the motive they want to attack SK. I don't know if you've read about NK's elite troops. Those guys are savages... cold-blooded killers... they would eat U.S. Army babies for lunch if the combat took place on the ground.
Re:PHd Student Uses Google Maps To Uncover N. Korea Secrets
by TriinT on Thursday June 04, 2009 @02:19AM
(#641033)
Yeah, we all know how effective the bombing of Serbia in 1999 was. The USAF cannot blow up hardened bunkers deep underground. You need boots on the ground to get the job done. And U.S. soldiers and marines would be brutally punished by the North Koreans as soon as they set foot on NK territory. You could count on thousands and thousands of flag-draped zinc caskets. Better keep negotiating until the only option left is the military one.
Re:PHd Student Uses Google Maps To Uncover N. Korea Secrets
by TriinT on Thursday June 04, 2009 @02:49AM
(#641059)
The point I am trying to make is simple: bombing a country is an act of war. If you start a war, you must be ready to face the consequences, including using ground forces to supplement the air raids. NK can't send bombers to attack the U.S. but they can cross the border and engage U.S. forces in SK. This would have to be carefully thought out... I don't have the intel to assess whether an attack on NK would be effective or not, and fortunately I don't have the power to send thousands of kids in harm's way.
This sort of validates their point, doesn't it? They let one guy in to look around, and next thing you know he's back in the US, annotating satellite maps in his spare time. Looking at it from their point of view, the rest of the world really is out to get them.
Too bad the cowardly U.S. government does not do anything but "negotiate".
Political opinion is welcome on this site in other threads, this just seems to be suppression of an unpopular point of view. It's also disingenuous to ask the poster questions about their POV and vote them down at the same time. If the questions are more than rhetorical (and if they're only rhetorical, then that's a waste of a post), then you should be willing to listen to the answers.
If you'd like HN to be a place w/o political discussions at all, then vote down the OP and the link--not the comments that follow.
Plus Kim Jong-il (and the military leaders) would have to be clinically insane to even dare launch a nuclear weapon at another country. US/UK/France/China/Russia have enough nukes to flatten the rest of the world...it'd be suicide!
Grab an M-16 and go get 'em!
Easier said than done, right?
-Sir Winston Churchill (1874-1965)
I would enjoy being a military pilot, and if I were, I'd volunteer for this mission.
I know nothing about NK's nuclear capabilities, but I doubt a few well-place JDAMS would do the job. Bombing nuclear facilities is not trivial. Israel did it successfully once, though.
A pre-emptive attack on NK could be a great idea, or it could be a disaster. There are thousands of U.S. soldiers in South Korea. An attack on NK would give them the motive they want to attack SK. I don't know if you've read about NK's elite troops. Those guys are savages... cold-blooded killers... they would eat U.S. Army babies for lunch if the combat took place on the ground.
I would be stronlgy opposed to a ground invasion. Your post appeals to the straw man fallacy by implying that I support a position I do not.