News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Show HN: Idea for Bugs Reporting Startup

Every once in awhile, while visiting some of my favourite sites, I find some bugs, both small & big.

1) For instance, if you click at More on TechCrunchTV in the footer of TC, it'll go to TechCrunch.tv which is redirected to TechCrunch.com

2) I just tried to submitted a set of free icons at IconFinders, despite the fact that I was sign in. It wouldn't let me submit the form at the last step. So I just stopped it for now (or will not try again at all).

The solution I propose is a directory, where any business can make a Wiki for bug reporting and the users can report bugs, vote on existing one, and other tools / feedback to help the site owners.

Why I think the solution will work, is because many time as a user we are out of time / energy to report the bug effectively on the site. Assuming it'll might go un-noticed.

On the other hands, sites can quickly fix their bugs if they are getting effective reporting and reward the reporter.

What are your thoughts? Someone please do it during the weekend.

( 4 comments | 4 points | on HN )
Re:Show HN: Idea for Bugs Reporting Startup by stevekemp on Sunday September 15, 2013 @03:56PM (#6390093)
The biggest problem I see here is that many companies keep their bug-lists to themselves, and actively do not wish to publish them in an externally visible fashion.

Open source projects benefit from having a public bug-tracker, but commercial entities like to pretend their software is bug-free and so they do not.

I wish you luck.

Re:Show HN: Idea for Bugs Reporting Startup by waqasaday on Sunday September 15, 2013 @04:36PM (#6390226)
I agree with the fact that businesses don't like to publish - but if such community is built the businesses will be benefited more than everyone.
Re:Show HN: Idea for Bugs Reporting Startup by mcintyre1994 on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @11:57AM (#6400018)
Are you sure about that? It seems that businesses wanting this is both crucial to the idea, but also unproven. For example, consider two very close competitors in the widget-making market, A and B. If A adds this, then:

1) They might get better bug reports and be able to fix them better, giving a less buggy product and making them better than B - good for A

2) A user reviewing both A and B might see that A has a list of bugs, and (most likely mistakenly)assume since B doesn't have such a list that B has no bugs. They assume B is better - bad for A

I suspect it depends on a lot of other factors which of those results is more pronounced, but it is unproven which way it would go for any given business.

Re:Show HN: Idea for Bugs Reporting Startup by TechpinesMary on Tuesday September 17, 2013 @10:57AM (#6399645)
Or, companies could do user tests, functional testing, etc. This service is pretty affordable: http://html5testing.co/