News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by bambax on Saturday September 14, 2013 @02:58PM (#6386658)
> even humanities faculty would go elsewhere if not compensated at the growing rate of their education bracket

But where would they go? Journalism??

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by pmiller2 on Saturday September 14, 2013 @10:02PM (#6387881)
In the limit, they would simply disappear. There wouldn't be any humanities faculty, aside from the independently wealthy, because nobody could make a living at it.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by mathattack on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:31PM (#6386757)
I don't think most humanities faculty are paid well. Perhaps the top few at the top schools, but the dropoff is enormous.

A better question may be is it worth it for the government to subsidize research for humanities professors? Or should humanities teachers have regular 9 to 5 teacher jobs?

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by slurry on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:40PM (#6386801)
A better question may be is it worth it for the government to subsidize research for humanities professors?

Where is all of this filthy lucre that the government is throwing at humanities professors? I would like to get some. The only federal body that funds pure humanities research is the National Endowment for the Humanities, which has a grand total of $150 million by way of annual budget. I.e. essentially zero.

Or should humanities teachers have regular 9 to 5 teacher jobs?

Perhaps HN commenters should have regular 9 to 5 jobs.

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by yuliyp on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:25PM (#6387117)
That comment is very misleading. The subsidy being talked about is not research subsidies, which pay lab costs and grad student stipends, not professors. Instead it's about tuition assistance in the form of student loans and grants. That's the subsidy that actually pays humanities profs.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by slurry on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:03PM (#6387410)
That comment is very misleading.

No it's not. I was responding directly to this:

A better question may be is it worth it for the government to subsidize research for humanities professors?

The article itself didn't have anything directly to say about the humanities as a field of study.

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by gte910h on Sunday September 15, 2013 @01:54PM (#6389695)
The govt loans are subsidizing them via tuition.

If loans were given out on a ability to repay standard, instead of govt guaranteed, humanities would get fewer loans, therefore, govt loans are subsidizing humanities faculty

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by slurry on Sunday September 15, 2013 @04:53PM (#6390293)
There was a contention that the government subsidizes humanities research. I demonstrated that, barring the rounding error that is the NEH, it does not. You reply that yes in fact the government does subsidize humanities teaching. I don't even know what to do with that.

Anyway, if loans were given out on an ability to repay standard then the biggest losses would be to health professions, criminal justice, early childhood education and other non-prestige career degrees toward which low income students tend to gravitate.

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by mathattack on Monday September 16, 2013 @06:11AM (#6392462)
The following are three forms of subsidies:

1) Schools are non-profits everything they do is subsidized.

2) Student loans subsidize schools.

3) State schools have in state subsidies.

If a professor is writing and researching, that is time and focus not spent teaching. If tenure is granted primarily on research, teaching suffers.

To those who think the status quo is fine, I ask: Are we in the correct balance of teaching and research in the humanities? If yes, how did we get there? And if there are strong cases for humanities research, why not more?

My opinion is much of what appears to be advancement of knowledge is really a system of misplaced incentives. You see this in teaching loads and overproduction of qualified humanities faculty relative to high school teachers.

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by dbecker on Saturday September 14, 2013 @08:25PM (#6387679)
Perhaps HN commenters should have regular 9 to 5 jobs.

Are you suggesting that most HN readers have easy jobs financed by government largesse?

That strikes me as an absurd suggestion.

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by 6d0debc071 on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:44PM (#6387176)
Law, art, literature, research, politics - there are lots of posts that require someone be capable of focused effort and thought. Perhaps it doesn't suit their current knowledge but they could learn new things - it's not like learning's hard if you're reasonably smart and able to sustain an interest.

Whether you think they just turn out nonsense or not they're in a fairly competitive environment and have managed to make a living there.