News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by dnautics on Saturday September 14, 2013 @02:40PM (#6386584)
what happened in 1981, when the price of college became unhinged from the CPI?
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by samtp on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:56PM (#6386865)
Student loans were exempted from bankruptcy, allowing banks to make riskier loans (more students, higher amounts). Colleges soon followed with increased tuition to match student's new ability to pay.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by dnautics on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:23PM (#6386943)
I am pretty sure that is a large part of why this is happening, but when was that signed into legislation?
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by nether on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:36PM (#6386983)
It's gotten progressively tougher since the '70s, starting with med/law school debt.

> Before the mid-1970s, debtors were able to get rid of student loans in bankruptcy court just as they could credit card debt or auto loans. But after scattered reports of new doctors and lawyers filing for bankruptcy and wiping away their student debt, resentful members of Congress changed the law in 1976.

> In an effort to protect the taxpayer money that is on the line every time a student or parent signs for a new federal loan, Congress toughened the law again in 1990 and again in 1998. In 2005, for-profit companies that lend money to students persuaded Congress to extend the same rules to their private loans.

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/01/business/shedding-student-...

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by dnautics on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:13PM (#6387445)
this doesn't match up with the hypothesis then.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by sliverstorm on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:53PM (#6387583)
What, because "Mid-70's" isn't the same as "1981"? It sometimes takes a little while for the ripples to be felt.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by dnautics on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:59PM (#6387602)
because, MD and JD debt wouldn't apply to undergrads, unless you think the wave can travel back in time?
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by atg2taa on Saturday September 14, 2013 @02:48PM (#6386619)
One hypothesis: the Bayh-Dole Act of 1980 [1], which allowed federal grantees to own the intellectual property developed with federal funds. Prior to this Act, all IP made with federal funds belonged to the government.

As R&D is extremely expensive, one theory is that colleges raised their tuition to help cover the venture capital requirements of research.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayh%E2%80%93Dole_Act

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by dnautics on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:26PM (#6386953)
I'm not certain this makes sense. Why would they need to raise tuition if the venture capital requirements were covered by the feds anyway? Moreover, typically gov't granted departments are helping pay for other departments through overhead, not the other way around.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by atg2taa on Saturday September 14, 2013 @06:02PM (#6387230)
I don't think federal grants cover the research costs completely. For example, if my professor wins one grant, part of the money will be put aside for to cover 10% of his salary. He certainly doesn't have 10 big grants in play at any given time, so the remainder has to be offset by the University.

Add to that, you need a lot of overhead like administrative assistants, grant managers, technology transfer officers.

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by jurassic on Saturday September 14, 2013 @06:54PM (#6387381)
I would be surprised if your professor's research tab is partly covered by the university unless they are using startup funds as a new faculty hire. The universities I've been at all (Caltech, MIT) have a significant "overhead" charge against all incoming grants to cover the cost of university infrastructure, keeping the lights on, etc. So it is research that is subsidizing the university, not the other way around.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by mjn on Saturday September 14, 2013 @08:53PM (#6387748)
The last sentence is somewhat questionable, except at the top universities. Only at the most grant-successful universities does the overhead actually break even in recouping the extra outlays universities put into research. Examples: construction of research-specific laboratory facilities, co-financing of expenditures they wouldn't have otherwise undertaken (many grants require co-funding), increased salaries and hiring packages caused by bidding wars for faculty who have successful grant-getting records, department backstopping of PhD stipends when a large group has a dry year grant-wise, salaries for grant-writing assistance and research-support staff, etc., etc.

The former Dean of Georgia Tech's College of Computing reached a similar conclusion: http://innovate-edu.com/2011/05/18/if-you-have-to-ask-ten-su...

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by dnautics on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:02PM (#6387405)
NIH keeps its overhead negotiations secret, but I know that The Scripps Research Institute, is currently at about 85%, schools like Harvard, MIT, and Caltech, Berkeley, Stanford, are hovering around that value right now, although IIRC in the past TSRI got 100% and there are rumors that some places got >100% overhead; the government in its budgetary crunch has begun reducing these figures.

DOE is slightly more parsimonious with its overhead, NSF is the most conservative. DARPA gives overhead in all sorts of ranges. Or so I hear.

And TSRI doesn't give most of its professors salary, unless they are doing "administrative duties" (Pres, VP, dept chair, etc) If you run out of grants, you basically don't get paid anymore. At one point ~90% of TSRI operating costs were run off of NIH overhead, all coming in from a very dynamic patchwork of grants from all of their PIs. I think then the pressure to keep getting grants made the place a bit of a boiler room, there was an uptick in shady science (Peter Schultz's retractions, Geoffrey Chang's retractions, and others I'm not ready to talk about yet)... Eventually professors started leaving because they didn't want to take it anymore.

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by secabeen on Sunday September 15, 2013 @01:13AM (#6388177)
Overhead is normally calculated as % of grant that goes to overhead. UC is around 50%, some of the Ivys are in the 60% range.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by dnautics on Sunday September 15, 2013 @01:36AM (#6388208)
that may be true for nonprofits, but that is not correct for federal science grants. Overhead is calculated as what % of the nominal amount you ask for is added on top for facilities. So a 100,000 grant plus 20% overhead costs 120,000. A 1M grant plus 60% overhead costs 1.6M.

That's because an agency like the NIH, will have a program project and decide, "ok. We want project X to be done and we think it will take ~150,000 in JUST science costs" - in theory, that should be more or less invariant across the institutions that get funded. THEN an added cost is what it takes for it to get done in X institution. If overhead were calculated as % of the full grant, then the math gets trickier to isolate the "invariant science part".

The reason why separating the "invariant science part" is important, is because when the agencies send out an program call, they say, "you get $2M to do the science", and each institute that is bidding to get the grant is not supposed to know how much of that gets taken up by overhead by other institutes. The net result is each institute is competing for the same pool of "we can do science with this" money without the PIs having to worry about how much of the cookie gets eaten up by their own institute. In general, I don't really like much of anything to do with the federal government's involvement with science, but: The way this is structured is probably a good thing, since scientists are really bad at thinking about much besides their own science, and if you make them do this mental gymnastic, something's going to come short, and there will probably be more failure all around from lack of funds. The responsibility to figure out how to get that administrative cost then falls on the program manager - and the grant reviewers are instructed to take overhead into account.

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by ahomescu1 on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:43PM (#6387173)
Can you give some examples or numbers for this? I find it hard to believe that this alone (or at least in large part) lead to such an increase in tuition. Most STEM research is still funded by the federal government (through the NSF, DARPA, NIH and similar agencies). Many research projects don't require venture capital, because they're not really marketable.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by atg2taa on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:52PM (#6387194)
Certainly. I haven't reserached this issue much, and while certainly other factors come into play, I suspect that Act does have an impact.

I used the word "venture capital" loosely. I do not refer to the traditional sense of VCs on sand hill road, but venture capital in the sense of money that can pay for extremely specialized and expensive research equipment and labor.

In general, the Harvardization ("we must be the best at all areas of research") has infected even second-tier research institutions; for places like Harvard, MIT, etc. the financial gains from patents probably outweighs the outlay. However, for second-tier research institutions, they may be simply caught up in a ratings arms race.

Here is a report that has some interesting facts.

http://www.ed.psu.edu/educ/cshe/working-papers/WP%236

'Over the current era, this has produced a pronounced intensification of research. For 99 research universities, enrollments grew by 15 percent from 1980 to 2000, but real research expenditures grew by 128 percent (Geiger, 2004, p. 147).'

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by ahomescu1 on Saturday September 14, 2013 @06:13PM (#6387269)
From the link you shared, I assume the relevant chart is the one on page 14, showing the growth of university research expenditures. What I couldn't find in the text (maybe I missed it) is the source of those funds; I think that most of it is paid not by universities, but by the federal government through various agencies. Like another commenter said, the university also receives money from research grants (as overhead), they don't have to pay anything except maybe the professors' salaries. A growth in "Research Expenditures" doesn't necessarily mean that universities are spending more money on research.

As an anecdote, here's my personal example. As a PhD student in CS at a public US university, my experience has been this: all our equipment (mostly computers, CS is relatively cheap) has been paid from grants, and I have been funded from 3 sources: a 1-year federal fellowship (FAFSA), 1 year as a TA (that one was funded by the university, but in exchange for teaching) and the rest on a federal research project.

Now, it is possible that richer private universities do pay for their own equipment and researchers. I don't have any numbers for that, though.

Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by anigbrowl on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:00PM (#6386877)
Wow, what a fucked-up piece of short-termism that was.
Re:The Supersizing of American Colleges by VLM on Sunday September 15, 2013 @09:38AM (#6389041)
If you pay cash, its unhinged.

On the other hand, if you are J6P and borrow the money you don't pay the cost, you pay a (fixed) monthly loan bill.

To about one sig fig, in constant dollars, at 20% interest aka 1980, you can borrow $30K for the same monthly payment as $150K at 3% aka 2010. Doesn't matter if they're "profit" or "non-profit" they're not leaving money on the table. Then factor in perhaps a factor of 4 in real world cost of living and nominal wages, and you can easily go from $3K in 1980 to $60K in 2010 without any "unhinging" happening at all.

Those are multi-generational extreme interest rates. It'll be "fun" to watch them revert to norms over a long enough run.

Its the same deal with property, for obvious reasons. The median dude will get the median education and live in the median house. The bank will get a constant median monthly payment. The centrally controlled interest rate will control what the providers get, but it won't affect joe6pack at all.