Even after she explained it she still received so many replies saying she was wrong, I just am wondering what's going on here that's causing this. That's just so bizarre.
It's actually a really big cognitive leap to get from there to the idea that, because the gameshow host knows the answer, that the visible answer differs from the mental shortcut.
I've got a good friend who speaks at a lot of risk management seminars, and a good deal of people who deal with financial risk every day get this question wrong. He's got a really good blog at http://behavioralrisk.net/
Yes. The difficulty with the Monty Hall problem has to do with grasping all the probabilities represented by all the outcomes at once. I personally didn't fully understand it until I wrote a list of all the possible outcomes and summed the probabilities.
I found her matrix rather messy & convinced myself with the following:
| chosen | revealed | hidden |
| car __ | empty __ | goat__ |
| empty_ | goat ___ | car __ |
| goat _ | empty __ | car __ |
I also like how she suggested that people just run the experiment themselves.
Suppose you have a million doors, you pick one, and the host opens the other 999,998 doors. Should you switch or not?
Clearly, clearly the prize is behind the unopened door, merely because the other door you picked had a one-in-a-million chance. Now it becomes a "so, do you think the prize is behind the door you picked, or the one I have conspicuously left unopened?".
You pick one door, the probability of winning is 1/N. The probability of losing is (N-1)/N, which stays fixed no matter how many doors the host opens. If you switch, the probability of winning is (1/(N-2))-(1/(1/N)).
If he opens all doors except two, and you switch, the probability of either of the two having the car is 50% minus the original 10^-6/2. Each door decreases the probability by one in a million, not one in a trillion. If that were the case, it would be highly unlikely that you won even if you switched after all but one of the doors were opened.
"Since you seem to enjoy coming straight to the point, I’ll do the same. You blew it! Let me explain. If one door is shown to be a loser, that information changes the probability of either remaining choice, neither of which has any reason to be more likely, to 1/2. As a professional mathematician, I’m very concerned with the general public’s lack of mathematical skills. Please help by confessing your error and in the future being more careful. -- Robert Sachs, Ph.D."
Doctor Sachs was entirely wrong, as were about ten thousand other academics who ganged up on Vos Savant in the months following the appearance of this column.
The real outcome is that, if the contestant doesn't change doors, his probability of winning is 1/3, but if he does change doors, his chance goes up to 2/3. Details:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem