We need to think about what we're about to lose.
(1) http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/19/world/europe/britain-detai...
If all else fails, stfu.
There's a time and a place for everything.
Who was it who has the shit attitude?
It isn't like there are many people left who haven't heard about it, and even if there were, the front page of HN has consistently contained several articles covering the NSA specifically for a number of weeks now.
My point is: why inhibit it no matter the context? Perhaps this is a new user who isn't privy to the daily dealings of hn? Maybe they aren't aware that their effort might be better spent on a less-informed forum? Why immediately dismiss and discourage their input?
My beef is and was with the tone of the post. No need to proclaim that God's work is being done; no need to be a dick.
Its a lot deeper than "the NSA". Something's bad wrong. And yeah, I'm going to preach about it until it gets fixed or I end up a crazy man on the corner wearing a sandwich board. (I believe that's what usually happens to those doing "God's work").
The end is near, bro.
http://bigstory.ap.org/article/govt-obtains-wide-ap-phone-re...
We need to not only protect those who report the news, whether they are traditional news people or new style, bloggers, from the government but at the same time we may need to find ways to prevent political parties from co-opting the media. Far too many are way to cozy with political groups and fail to realize when they voluntarily give up their freedoms.
In reality, it's usually subdued pressure or tacit awareness that someone above you can make things go badly and you have no recourse.
I'm not sure the comments will stop, unless there's a policy reversal.
...the point being that 'government' is not a unitary entity.
Furthermore, I don't think you're the arbiter of how HN discussions need to go down - so while you're entitled to talk about why you personally find a topic worthy of repeated discussion, trying to frame your individual opinion as a matter of objective fact is a rather cheap rhetorical trick unless you're speaking on pg's behalf.
Sorry, I forgot that position was taken. (he says, without a trace of apparent irony)
It was emotive and brought attention to a terrible situation. But on objective measures of quality journalism, I see better articles daily in tabloid newspapers.
If the article wasn't so emotionally effective (and we didn't agree with its point of view) it might be more obvious that it was full of half-truths, weasel words and confusing narration.
Most writing intended to be convincing (see marketing copy, political rhetoric etc) steers well clear of the facts or twists them so as to be unreliable. That doesn't make it any less convincing.
It is easy to notice when you disagree with the writer's point, but I don't think having a noble purpose automatically makes a piece of writing a "masterpiece".
Now ask yourself what would have happened if those in power had a bunch of warrantless "dirt" on these particular journalists and decided that they'd really rather just keep the gravy train rolling.
We all have something to hide and something to fear.