If the host is capable of providing more power like 2.1A for example, how is that supposed to be signaled to the phone when the data lines are floating high? The way a USB charger that provides more current than the USB spec works is by pulling the data lines either to some voltage or shorting them together or to ground. Either way you need the data lines to negotiate that.
So it'll depend on how nice of a device you have.
http://www.extremetech.com/computing/115251-how-usb-charging... http://learn.adafruit.com/minty-boost/icharging
Like the MAX14636: http://www.maximintegrated.com/datasheet/index.mvp/id/7968
There are always risks, so we just have to choose the less risky option available to us.
So between these two...
A. The black box charging station I know nothing about.
B. The simple device that I brought from home whose single purpose is to limit my exposure to external risk.
I'll take the latter.
Odds are I'm no worse off than had I plugged directly into the charging station.
If that and other things you claim are real issues then, every dumb usb power brick, every old computer/old charger, every non-apple charger, and others would all have problems.
It is? I've never had any problems with cheap AC to USB power adapters.
Note: I am in no way affiliated with the above kickstarter
1. The data lines can be very important in regulating power output for different devices, and there are different maximums for different versions of USB. Some devices require data communication to charge. Some require proprietary protocols. Implementing Apple product charging is somewhat convoluted, for example, and has changed over time.
2. A friend of mine is a computer engineer, and tells me that correctly implementing USB in hardware is incredibly difficult. It's possible that devices like these might be skimping on parts of the spec to more easily get a working product out the door.