News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Companies Founded By College Dropouts Rarely Hire Col... by bdcravens on Friday September 13, 2013 @01:43AM (#6378858)
A degree doesn't make you an adult, nor does the lack of one make you less of an adult. I had a bigger point I was trying to make, and I apologize if I missed the mark and struck a nerve.

I'm addressing the article's idea that you can take a kid in college out of college and somehow that's a magical formula.

Becoming a adult means leaving home, becoming your own person (not in the high school "I'm finding myself..." sense), and experiencing success and failure purely of your own accord.

The author I feel referred to the Thiel folks as children because they hadn't crossed these thresholds. Adulthood in my sense of the word seems to me to be a necessary prerequisite for business success. Collge can help a person grow in these areas of their life. It's no guarantee, and it's possible to grow outside of college.

What doesn't work is taking a kid who lived in mommy and/or daddy's house, went to college on mommy/daddy's dime, and drove the car they were given, and then have someone come along and become a new mommy/daddy holding their hand while they start a business. I don't think anyone can be successful without having experience success, and perhaps even more importantly, failure.

My outlook is filtered by my own experience. I've lived on my own since age 17, and didn't get my first car until age 23 (because the only way I could get one was to buy it myself.. my entire childhood, my parents didn't have a car). I was a college dropout (wanted to stay, couldn't afford it, and made mistakes with regard to student loans that I was to blame for). No computer in my home until I bought one myself. Taught myself programming, built up a career over time. No hand holding, everything I have I paid for, and I have no safety net. That said, I've made plenty of mistakes, and I deserve everything I have, nor don't have, right now.

Perhaps that leaves me bitter; I don't think so. I see a situation like the Thiel Fellowship and see the total lack of success as a blatantly obvious conclusion. (Though it's probably wrong to judge, as I know nothing about these "entrepreneurs" and their life experience)

There are no comments on this comment yet.