1. That is hardly consensus theory: it is one hypothesis postulated by a small group of scientists, which is somewhat plausible but is very far from having a compelling body of evidence in support of it.
2. The theory is that vaccinations in the 19th century may have caused HIV due to unsterile injections given to many natives. Vaccination practice in the 21st century is much different from vaccination practice in the 19th century, and unsterile injections will cause all sorts of other problems.
Regarding point 2, the lesson to be learned I think is that with vaccines there is a relatively large chance of black swan type issues coming up. And even if there were a way to catch these sorts of problems, the medical system isn't designed to even look for them.
There are no longer any rational arguments against the most common vaccines.
What about the 30 million people who have died of the AIDS epidemic, which is thought to have been started because of government vaccination programs?[1]
Similarly, what about the fact that the US government has been repeatedly caught giving out fake vaccinations?[2] Or the fact that the safety standards for medicine in the US are generally abysmal?[3]
All in all I think getting vaccinated is generally a good bet, but the idea that there are no rational arguments against vaccination is completely disingenuous.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_HIV/AIDS
[2] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/jul/11/cia-fake-vaccin...
[3] http://www.amazon.com/Bad-Pharma-Companies-Mislead-Patients/...