News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by swamp40 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @05:28PM (#6377078)
It is for beauty like this that I believe all living things were originally designed by some intelligence, somewhere.

Perhaps designed to mutate and evolve, or perhaps that was a limitation in the source materials, but there are some beautifully engineered living systems on our planet.

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by shmageggy on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:04PM (#6377301)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teleological_argument

What I was looking for but didn't find in the article was an explanation (or even a hypothesis) for how this mechanism evolved. One of the things I find most fascinating about evolution is how seemingly irreducible complexity in nature always turns out to have a some path of mutations and adaptations that led to the current state. For instance, the canonical example of 18th century teleology, the eye, was touted as being so unimaginably complex that there's the only conceivable explanation for its existence was design, yet today we have a clear picture of how that organ arose from simple photorecptive cells. My guess in this instance? The friction plates that their ancestors have and the other species have got bumpy, then they got more bumpy, then they interleaved.

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by Slackwise on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:27PM (#6377416)
Just because something looks "engineered", doesn't mean it is.

A perfect example is the eye. An organ of great complexity, but one that is very easily explained by logical evaluation, as well as existing living creatures and fossils: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nwew5gHoh3E

If you're a software engineer, I hope you understand how procedural systems and algorithms can transform data and functions. Similar processes take place via chemistry and biological interaction. Conway's Game of Life is a good example of a simple system giving rise to complex interaction and patterns.

Complex beauty can arise from the interaction of systems, but if you say to yourself that it "must have been engineered by something greater than me", you settle in your mind, and shortcut around critical thinking and never progress toward understanding. And that's a great, great shame.

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by pygy_ on Thursday September 12, 2013 @07:16PM (#6377618)
What more, the vertebrate eye has a flaw: its blind spot. The fibers of the optic nerve and the central retinal blood vessels irradiate in front of the retina.

You may think that it is a necessary defect, but the squid eye, which evolved independently to end up almost identical to its vertebrate counterpart doesn't have it. The nerve fibers and blood vessels run behind the retina.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cephalopod_eye

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by swamp40 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @07:08PM (#6377589)
I'm a hardware engineer.

I agree with you about patterns and mathematics - also beautiful, but cold (sorry, best I can explain it).

But when we see a complex physical problem, and then see a nicely designed and implemented real-life solution - there I think my "engineered" theory has as good a chance at being correct as does the theory that says it just sprang up from 100 million years of evolution and random mutations (both of which I agree do occur).

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by beauSD on Friday September 13, 2013 @07:47PM (#6383940)
As a software engineer, when I see an algorithm that transforms and processes data using instructions and symbols, I reasonably assume that someone created that algorithm.

When I'm told the algorithm is really just a random collection of instructions, assembled through an unguided process, that just happens to be work...that strains belief. But even accepting that, I'm still left with instructions, language, symbols, and interpretation. And these can only be produced by intelligence.

Something as simple as the characters we use to write code means nothing unless meaning is ascribed to them, and meaning can't arise from a strictly meaningless process (evolution, chemical interactions, etc). I think the simpler, and truer explanation for why these systems appear engineered, is because they are.

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by chockablock on Thursday September 12, 2013 @05:42PM (#6377150)
non sequitur. Why does beauty imply the existence of an intelligent designer?
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by swamp40 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @05:49PM (#6377193)
Engineering beauty.

Like a Saturn V rocket, or an AC induction motor.

Things that make you proud to be an engineer.

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by biomecha on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:03PM (#6377292)
So that intelligence would be able to feel proud of something? That's a very human concept.
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by iron_ball on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:13PM (#6377348)
God cannot feel pride, for that would imply the possibility of failure. God is beyond most human emotions, probably all, for that reason: our emotions imply their opposites, while for God, there are no alternatives other than what is -- which is by definition perfect.

Mind you, I'm an atheist, so this is just my understanding of the argument.

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by biomecha on Thursday September 12, 2013 @07:54PM (#6377741)
But that's assuming that intelligence fit the definition of a unique, christian like perfect god. Why would it have to be? Isn't it limiting the scope unecessarily?
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by iron_ball on Friday September 13, 2013 @10:28AM (#6380680)
Absolutely. Christianity is just one possible frame.
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by swamp40 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:12PM (#6377339)
Well, I was just explaining why I used the word beauty.

Maybe whatever created these gears was being tortured by an evil master until it made something satisfactory.

I really can't say for sure...

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by GravityWell on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:19PM (#6377378)
It doesn't. In this context, "...that I believe all living things", the words "I believe" can be directly converted to "I have faith without any evidence".
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by fakeanon on Friday September 13, 2013 @07:31AM (#6379764)
> It is for beauty like this that [I believe][I have faith without any evidence] all living things were originally designed by some intelligence, somewhere.

Looks like this for is as in "because", he is telling you why he belives, because of "beauty like this". You can only say you do not believe this evidence implicates that.

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by dsuth on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:19PM (#6377375)
You're fitting the data to support your preconceived ideas. That never works out well.
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by swamp40 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @10:49PM (#6378274)
Well, I can't disagree with that.
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by snowwrestler on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:07PM (#6377313)
Evolution is the ultimate proof of the power of agile engineering--ship on a schedule, test with real data, then work on the next iteration, keeping the good and discarding the bad.
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by emiljbs on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:23PM (#6377398)
Except that the new iteration is pretty much making random changes.
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by dragonwriter on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:37PM (#6377459)
> Except that the new iteration is pretty much making random changes.

E.g., avoiding ivory tower planning and instead using empirical, in-the-wild A/B testing.

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by to3m on Thursday September 12, 2013 @08:13PM (#6377819)
...over tens of thousands of years.
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by snowwrestler on Thursday September 12, 2013 @10:16PM (#6378176)
A common misperception but not true, because traits are heritable and the environment selects for fitness.

Mutation and genetic drift play a role in evolution, but are not the sole source of changes.

Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by dsego on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:26PM (#6377415)
But if the environment suddenly changes you die out.
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by CatMtKing on Thursday September 12, 2013 @07:02PM (#6377570)
Or adapt... depending on how shallowly you demarcate a population of organisms and how initially resilient they are to the environmental change.
Re:First Mechanical Gear Found in a Living Creature by lotsofcows on Friday September 13, 2013 @05:05AM (#6379339)
Every time you see something ugly, do you change your mind?