Re:Pushed to the limit as a banking intern
by crusso on Thursday September 12, 2013 @05:31PM
(#6377091)
in both cases true freedom is constrained by a background set of rules enforced by the state
No Lord God Mises necessary. The rules for "pure" capitalism are the minimum set needed to allow free exchange between individuals.
Re:Pushed to the limit as a banking intern
by eli_gottlieb on Thursday September 12, 2013 @05:45PM
(#6377174)
Only if you've redefined "capitalism" to mean "any economic system including individual/institutional holdings and trade", in which case you've successfully and retroactively redefined all economies ever as having been capitalistic. A net that catches every fish names none.
Re:Pushed to the limit as a banking intern
by tptacek on Thursday September 12, 2013 @07:05PM
(#6377581)
"A net that catches every fish names none" is an interesting turn of phrase. Does it come from somewhere? Nets don't usually name things; the net that catches only 2 fishes also doesn't name them.
Re:Pushed to the limit as a banking intern
by eli_gottlieb on Thursday September 12, 2013 @07:21PM
(#6377634)
No, my brain just mixed metaphors stupidly. It just sounds interesting because it alliterates, which is also by accident.
I was thinking about how tuna fishermen cast dragnets that often catch many other things, up to and including sharks and dolphins. Hence, you couldn't really call such a net a "tuna net", since it more just catches tuna by coincidence of catching everything even remotely fish-shaped.
Re:Pushed to the limit as a banking intern
by mdpopescu on Saturday September 14, 2013 @06:36AM
(#6385213)
I think you missed the "free" part of the definition. The trade between the North Korean death camp guard and a prisoner is between individuals but that doesn't make it capitalistic (because of that "free" part being absent).
The difference between capitalism and regulated economies is not freedom, because in both cases true freedom is constrained by a background set of rules enforced by the state. Rather, the difference is what rules exist and who makes them. In a purely capitalist society, we defer to the Lord God Mises and declare a a particular set of rules (private property, private contracts, etc) to be sacrosanct and worthy of government protection. In a democratic society, we get to vote on the rules.