Re:Apple’s Fingerprint ID May Mean You Can’t ‘Take the Fifth’
by ctdonath on Friday September 13, 2013 @09:35AM
(#6380320)
And if the phone was not used for a call?
I'm not contending the "wasn't really yours" point. Phones get stolen, misplaced, left behind, etc. with enough frequency that "it's your phone and it registered/triangulated with this position" may be strong circumstantial evidence but still isn't proof. That it was used in a manner requiring your finger (still attached to your body) does.
Don't get me wrong, I'm with you on protecting the accused from compulsion to self-incrimination. Just observing that the fingerprint sensor, coupled with the enormous data being collected on/about the device, isn't helping 5th Amendment rights.
The phone company can testify that the phone corresponds to a given cell number. Other people can testify that they spoke to the defendant on that number. No one piece of evidence exists in a vacuum; all the pieces of evidence combine to paint a picture.
Sure you could try to lie by making up stories about how the phone wasn't really yours, but it's hard to get all the other evidence to line up with a lie. This is a GOOD thing; the protection against self-incrimination isn't intended to help people get away with murder, it's intended to protect the accused from being compelled to help the government prosecute them.