Your claim is that what I said is false.
> Sure, some commands need you to switch modes, but not all.
Your claim is that what I said is true.
Only one of the above comments can be so. If one is true, then the other is false. Take your pick.
That's for sure. In a single post he asserted both that there are modes, and there aren't modes. That leaves no room for another viewpoint.
There's one sure way to win an argument -- assert all possible viewpoints, declare victory, and depart the field.
Far from "[asserting] all possible viewpoints", I mentioned specific keystrokes that you could try out too. If you are in insert-mode, and use arrow keys to visit a different location, you'd continue to be in insert-mode. Is it implemented as a secret hack to quietly enter and exit the scroll mode when arrow keys are pressed? I neither know nor care. However, in this usage scenario, modes are not exposed to the end-user.
* actually, I do like modal behaviour, but in very few cases. In MS Windows, it used to be the case that Win-space z would put the window in resize-mode. One could then use arrow keys to resize the window. There was a similar sequence for moving windows too.
> * To perform multiple operations, like moving the cursor around, entering text, deleting text, searching the document, saving and loading files, requires you to switch modes. Just like vi.
Open a file. Insert some text. Use arrow keys to scroll. Hit Alt-/ to search forward. Hit Alt-Shift-/ to search backwards. Sure, some commands need you to switch modes, but not all.
> * It cannot take advantage of the modern computing environment -- mouse navigation, different fonts, text styling, page layout, or anything else. Just like vi.
One can do text styling (but only with colours, I think) with vim. With gvim, one can use a mouse, and change fonts.